samcantstandya

If we give them anything better than pick 27 I will spew.

Still far convinced about Matt Jones. I still rate him NQR and a candidate to be delisted along with Terlich, Newton, Michie and a few others

The footy department must have had a worst case scenario. To not factor that in would be very amateurish. I think they were too hasty and Goodwin has to take responsibility for that. If we got him for a later pick ok, but to give up a second round pick and not have him in the system for a year is very poor. Although at least we didn't give up what the Saints did.

So an upgrade on Matt Jones. Well no disrespect to Matt, but we need a whole lot better than that. We lose on the trade scenario. So the computer says no.

We went after Riley who was NQR etc, we have to stop getting stop gap players. I want us to go for quality or go for youth in the draft. I especially don't want us to trade with Essendon they are notoriously unrealistic and want overs.

I totally agree.

Not happy if true.

Essendon want Howe & a 2nd rounder for him. Why bother trying to trade with them they want to screw you over. Besides Melksham is a vanilla midfielder and I prefer chocolate.

Don't know how u can [possibly rate him higher. Watts and Howe are elite in one facet Melksham in none. I hope we don't get him.

They deserve him.

Can't see where it mentions us offering him 4 years in the above link. I don't want anyone from Essendon especially Melksham who is a bland type of footballer.

I hope this is not true.

Not a fan - pass.

Not convinced. Hope if they do resign him give him a year not 2 or 3. Otherwise more potential deadwood.

No way trade McDonald.

Jedcock isn't good enough 4 Lions, but let's take him. No more NQRs or those at the end of their prime I'm sick of us been seen as a retirement home.

I cringed when I first heard we were keen 2 get Dawes, just like years ago when we traded pick 20 for Ben Holland.

The longer the delay the more likely that one or both are goneski especially if Howe was offered big money from GWS. Shame about Howe is that he is one of the few on our list who the kids like to follow.

Judd in his prime over Hodge.

Definitely

We need 2 weed out all our NQRs..

I'd prefer to draft 2 of them.

I agree totally.

Good strategy

I thought this year with Clark gone Fitzy would become a fixture. But he hasn't still could though. Don't like his high ball drop when kicking for goal, but he has that rare asset for a big man speed. He can pinch hit in the ruck. As much as Pedersen has improved I still prefer Fitzy over him as Ped at times seems disinterested tired or lazy.