samcantstandya

Whilst endeavour and second efforts are great, we need players who can convert and are good kicks

Needs to go back to Casey and only get a game in the seniors if he suddenly becomes a more physical player. I highly doubt that he will so he's a certainty to be delisted at the end of year. Luker shows more physical presence and deserves to be developed.

Delist at end of the year can't kick a goal or ruck. Looks like he doesn't like the contact. I'll be annoyed if they offer him another contract. Why do we think ex fringe Brisbane players will somehow click

He has no physical presence. Can't take a mark and should make way for Roo. He'll be delisted at year's end.

Do you think he'll make it???

That will mean White will have to nominate us

We have abandoned the Irish experiment to our detriment.

I think you're a good judge M_9. Spargs has high footy nous

Not sure Sharp deserves to stay in

Get Jeff to talk to him about his move to Freo but then. Maybe Kossie might forget about it then??

My Dees garden gnome has either run away or is hiding from embarrassment. He/she/they/them/ze/hir/ey.......etc have suffered at the hands of the team for the last 20 games and is tired of the constant ridicule from neighbouring gnomes. For the sake of him, her etc please can the players lower their eyes and find a someone in the 4ward 50. If the players can't or won't then join my garden gnome in hiding.

Hate hearing the line it's only round 5 and it's a long season. We have lost 15 out of the last 20 games, we concede so much 4th quarter goals. Our experienced players are repeat offenders and blaze away into forward 50. You'd think we'd have a decent forward coach, we are so boring to watch.

I think we draft well, but recruit poorly eg Bilings, Sharp etc

Was Lewis selfless at the Dees ?????

It's extremely frustrating, annoying, maddening and soul destroying watching him kick long to a contest, ignoring short options only to see the ball slingshot back for an opposition goal.

If only Captain Parmenter were in the side.

We'd be better off without supporters like him he likes stacking crud on us and always attacks us.

I'm disappointed that Gawn said that they "broke our spirit" - makes us sound very weak

AJ has only played 2 games. I haven't seen him, is he not up to it???

Melksham needs to find form at Casey first.

Hore reinjuring his calf doesn't bode well - they call it an old man's injury and they can be very problematic

If that's the case, then it makes sense that we are a very inaccurate team when shooting for goal

I think we should play McDonald as the relief ruck up forward/wing then Turner can play TMac's role in defence. We should play Fritsch closer to goal and Roo at CHF

Spargo

I'd have him back. We hopefully still have a good relationship with him. We need a ruck once Max retires. I'd give them future picks etc....