38 players used in 07, anymore to add

[WonnaJurah 5]

wow, this year pretty much everyone has played for the mfc, other then bode,hayes,weetra ,neeves and hughes

any of these chance to play in 07

[John Dee 445]

wow, this year pretty much everyone has played for the mfc, other then bode,hayes,weetra ,neeves and hughes

any of these chance to play in 07

Poor old Heath Neville, the forgotten man.

[kryton 0]

Poor old Heath Neville, the forgotten man.

During yesterdays telecast Commettie (sp?) said somthing like if you are healthy on Melbournes and still not getting a game then you'd be wondering.

[WonnaJurah 5]

also only 4 have played full years

carroll,white,davey and junior are only ones to play full year, with carroll injured apaprently, that leaves 3 in

whites played 85 games in a row as well

[Nicho 1]

wow, this year pretty much everyone has played for the mfc, other then bode,hayes,weetra ,neeves and hughes

any of these chance to play in 07

The players that Melbourne have not tries this year are;

Heath Neville

Issac Weetra

Jace Bode#

Daniel Hayes#

Daniel Hughes#

Shane Neaves #

#rookie listed

[Jaded No More 68,867]

Clint Bartram played one game this year after overcoming his ankle injury, then did his knee at training!

Of the players who haven't played this year, 4 are rookies who can't be elevated as we've missed the cut-off date.

Weetra has been injured most of the season, and Neville is still playing in the Sandy reserves.

We're pretty much down to 24 players to select from this weekend.

[Nicho 1]

Clint Bartram played one game this year after overcoming his ankle injury, then did his knee at training!

Of the players who haven't played this year, 4 are rookies who can't be elevated as we've missed the cut-off date.

Weetra has been injured most of the season, and Neville is still playing in the Sandy reserves.

We're pretty much down to 24 players to select from this weekend.

Correct. Good work Jaded, Bartram did play a game before injury this season.

[dazzledavey36 54,277]

wouldn't mind giving shane neaves or even jace bode a go if we are really down to numbers.

[Kit Walker 225]

Of the players who haven't played this year, 4 are rookies who can't be elevated as we've missed the cut-off date.

Weetra has been injured most of the season, and Neville is still playing in the Sandy reserves.

We're pretty much down to 24 players to select from this weekend.

Wasn't aware of this, when was the cut-off date?

Any word on Bruce's injury? Channel 7 said it was a hamstring at training but nothing more.

[Jumping Jack Clennett 1,778]

Wasn't aware of this, when was the cut-off date?

It must be this week, if this is correct, since I heard one of the other clubs has elevated a rookie for next match.

[jacey 333]

Wasn't aware of this, when was the cut-off date?

It must be this week, if this is correct, since I heard one of the other clubs has elevated a rookie for next match.

Alwyn Davey's on the long term injury list which allows Rama to stay on the senior list.

We've got lots of long term injuries so it's why we don't elevate Neaves. The best of the rookies and the only deserving.

Is money the issue again as mfc can't scrounge up a few dollars to pay Neaves?

[Rogue 585]

Alwyn Davey's on the long term injury list which allows Rama to stay on the senior list.

We've got lots of long term injuries so it's why we don't elevate Neaves. The best of the rookies and the only deserving.

Is money the issue again as mfc can't scrounge up a few dollars to pay Neaves?

I fail to see the point in upgrading someone simply for the sake of it.

Neaves is way behind White & PJ in the pecking order. I wouldn't drop one of them for the sake of bringing in Neaves - what would it achieve? Not much IMO.

Can see why people want to see youngsters, but it's going a bit far.

[jacey 333]

I fail to see the point in upgrading someone simply for the sake of it.

True but Neaves is a playa i like to try. White's not a ruckmen anymore. He's a tall midfielder who can jump.

[Jarka 767]

wouldn't mind giving shane neaves or even jace bode a go if we are really down to numbers.

A definite yes to Neaves. He's been very, very good at Sandy and I think a taste of AFL footy would just encourage him to work even harder. Not sure about Bode though.

[WonnaJurah 5]

Wasn't aware of this, when was the cut-off date?

It must be this week, if this is correct, since I heard one of the other clubs has elevated a rookie for next match.

rama got elevated in place of davey thats y

[DemonDave 1,089]

also only 4 have played full years

carroll,white,davey and junior are only ones to play full year, with carroll injured apaprently, that leaves 3 in

whites played 85 games in a row as well

You'd think based on these numbers, and the way our best&Fairest is voted on, that Junior would be a short

priced favorite to defend his prize...

[Rogue 585]

True but Neaves is a playa i like to try. White's not a ruckmen anymore. He's a tall midfielder who can jump.

Fair enough, but it seems Jamar is being picked in front of Neaves for Sandy this week and it's a big step up.

I imagine Neaves will be on the list next year, so I'm sure he'll get a chance if he's good enough.

[Jarka 767]

Fair enough, but it seems Jamar is being picked in front of Neaves for Sandy this week and it's a big step up.

I imagine Neaves will be on the list next year, so I'm sure he'll get a chance if he's good enough.

They also started Newton on the bench a couple of weeks ago

[Rogue 585]

They also started Newton on the bench a couple of weeks ago

I think Sandringham has at least one key forward not eligible to play for MFC while Jamar and Neaves are only competing against each other.

Anyhow, I was just using at as an illustration of Neaves' stocks compared to PJ and White - right now he's a long way back, regardless of what some may say about White's ability as a ruckman.