would you be happy with 2 goals 7, 6 free kicks against, and a disposal efficiency of around 60% from a $10mil player?

Jazza wear his stAins on the outside,proudly,hayseed style.

I think both Tippett and Buddy should send a letter of thanks to Clarko for firstly playing and then keeping Cheney in the back line all night, he was terrible, too small and not enough skill to make up for the lack of height.

I think both Tippett and Buddy should send a letter of thanks to Clarko for firstly playing and then keeping Cheney in the back line all night, he was terrible, too small and not enough skill to make up for the lack of height.

Probably becuase he was poorly developed at Melbourne...

He's spectacular, selfish, not a team player, I have always rated Roughead as the better of the two.

give me an honest forward who will give me 3 goals and a contest a game over a bloke who might kick 7 one week, then none the next but blaze and ignore 7 options in better positions to take pot shots

It's just my opinion I suppose

and to think we had a chance to grab Roughy back some years ago when he was in a buddy slump. I was interested. I thought he was suffering in the Buds shadow at that time.

Probably becuase he was poorly developed at Melbourne...

Probably but he's been at Hawthorn longer than he was at Melbourne and last night he showed very little to indicate he was up to it.

Probably becuase he was poorly developed at Melbourne...

watch this space.

obviously the hawks see enough in Kyle to work to develop him, even if he's fighting above his division.

Probably but he's been at Hawthorn longer than he was at Melbourne and last night he showed very little to indicate he was up to it.

I was joking.

I was joking.

I thought so.

I think they have a few problems in their back line and Shoenemakers(?) seems to be a bit of a front runner; I have nothing against Cheney and was disappointed when we moved him on but he was a flanker at best imo.