Nic Nat

[jnrmac 20,055]

I reckon he is overrated, would much rather see us pick up mundy for a couple of years, Goldstein is a free agent this year but we'd have to pay overs to get him

Me too,. And I reckon not many are in that camp.

His highlight reel is great but he doesn't do it anywhere near often enough,

Pass

[nutbean 8,838]

An infrequent one at that.

He was injury ravaged last year. Have a look at his 2012 where he also shared duties with Cox and his 2011 wasnt bad either.

[McQueen 17,864]

He was injury ravaged last year. Have a look at his 2012 where he also shared duties with Cox and his 2011 wasnt bad either.

Injuries aside the hype around Natainui isn't relative to his output. He's capable of some freakish things but my point was regards his general consistency.

I listened to Simmo on ABC Perth yesterday and he's not even sold on Natainui yet. He reckons as an opposition coach you never really took much notice of specific players until you were actually playing them (referring to his days at the Hawks). Seems he's not been sucked into all of the hype surrounding him. Wonder what he thinks of the $5M on offer..

[dee-luded 2,959]

With Nic-Nat coming out of contract do we give ourselves any chance of putting up an offer that could tempt him? I'm sure Frawley would be looked at by West Coast as a perfect replacement for Glass next year.

I think we need to tie in Frawls...

Nik Nat could go to GWS, a great fit for them in their varied cultures. & maybe WC_Eagles need a tall Power Forward like Patton? or god forbid, Clark?

[dee-luded 2,959]

As people have mentioned, overrated, very overrated. I'd much rather us look at getting Fyfe for 800k per year. Gawn will step up and so will the other Max, King, we'll be right with our rucks.

I think he's about to come of age.

this year should see him take the No 1 ruck, & his footy will grow from there.

[pitmaster 3,519]

It's easy to say an opposition player is over-rated, and in this case it's even easier than usual.

Possibly THE most over-rated player in the comp...EVER.

Unless you count Craig Starcevic.