Since Saturday most of us are over "all things footy" at least until next Saturday:) Life as a Melbourne Supporter.

Lots of fellow members have been calling for the scalps of practically the entire list plus the Coach.

IMO as a life long Demon that the Neeld appointment was the wrong choice but would sacking him help?

Given Neeld has entirely revamped the game plan and players are still in a period of adjustment would it be a mistake to CULL our youth as most seem to be advocating in a recent RR Topic. Wouldn't that mean the new Guys coming in will need another year to grasp the Neeld Way? The Devil you know argument?

OK...We have all sat back in our comfy seats in the Northern and said...ahhh why did we let him go? Yes?

In the last 25 years which Melbourne Players have been "let go" and thrived in another environment?

What players are Melbourne likely to trade or de-list that may thrive at another club?

Post removed.Pourquoi?

There's really less than 10 AFL players on the list at the moment and I doubt Neeld is letting them go anywhere but the gym.

Compared to Buckley,Miller,Bruce or Mclean the ones that will go are second rate so I wouldnt worry about it too much.

Players walking out might tell another story, but then Scully is hardly setting the world on fire either

Edited July 30, 201213 yr by IRW

This thread exists already .