Not yet.

They both wear 35 I'll give you that.

Heres their stats at the same age.

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_compare?tid1=12&pid1=3331&tid2=10&pid2=232&type=A&fid1=O&fid2=O

While stats don't show the whole picture, it does show that Chapman was not always as good as he is now.

Tapscott has a hell of a lot of development in him.

Stuart Dew, Aaron Hamill, Ryan OKeefe. Just a few handy forwards which Tapscott should be aiming to emulate.

I respect your opinion. I just disagree with limiting him to the backline. I would love to know Tapscott's own thoughts on where he should be played.

I find Tapscott one of the harder players on our list to project.

He has a strong body, but he really hasn't done a lot of preseason running. The question is about how good a runner he can become. Chapman became a really good runner after a slow start. If Tappy has it in him then he could become someone who plays bursts in the midfield.

If he doesn't then he'll be a fringe player or a role player.

I'd love to see him do a proper preseason. We'll have a better idea after he gets some proper running into him..

Would love to ee Jetta covers Tappy's current role in the bacline so Luke can play of the HFF...

Big kick, will be our chappy if given the chance