I think the forum would really benefit from a Player discussion forum where there's a thread per player. Players develop over time and it's interesting to see the comment as they progress. A continuous Jamar thread would be fascinating and I think a Morton one would be too. Posters opinions vary over time too, this woulld also be a source of interest. The recent Joel Macdonald thread is a good example where it would be great to have continuity in the duscussion over the years forward.

The Cale Morton thread would be a battleground.

I think the forum would really benefit from a Player discussion forum where there's a thread per player. Players develop over time and it's interesting to see the comment as they progress. A continuous Jamar thread would be fascinating and I think a Morton one would be too. Posters opinions vary over time too, this woulld also be a source of interest. The recent Joel Macdonald thread is a good example where it would be great to have continuity in the duscussion over the years forward.

Thats not a bad idea, views vary from week to week.

Over time it would be open slather for some that didnt rate player X any chance etc etc

It would be interesting to look back on personal views on some players.

Keeping it on topic might be the problem, discussing one player leads to comparing to another

before long, its off topic.

The Cale Morton thread would be a battleground.

Amen to that

It could be a brilliant idea but it also could be a nightmare for the mods as threads could degenerate into player bashing and abuse. I'll put it to the mods and see what they think.