Melbourne v Richmond

9 James Frawley (Melb)

8 Lynden Dunn (Melb)

7 Brad Green (Melb)

3 Daniel Jackson (Rich)

2 Aaron Davey (Melb)

1 Tom Scully (Melb)

I wonder what Frawley did wrong to have 1 point subtracted from a possible 10. Riewoldt kick 1 goal too many??

Well...

From that you can deduce:

Coach A

5 Frawley

4 Green

3 Dunn

2 Jackson

1 Scully

Coach B

5 Dunn

4 Frawley

3 Green

2 Davey

1 Jackson

Obviously you can't tell which coach voted which way and both the 2 & 1 votes could swap sides (together).

Had 3 clangers.

Well...

From that you can deduce:

Coach A

5 Frawley

4 Green

3 Dunn

2 Jackson

1 Scully

Coach B

5 Dunn

4 Frawley

3 Green

2 Davey

1 Jackson

Obviously you can't tell which coach voted which way and both the 2 & 1 votes could swap sides (together).

Agreed. At a guess, I would say Bailey = Coach A ; Hardwick = Coach B. Just a hunch. Only because I think Bailey* may have recognised more how important Scully was in the last quarter and may have been inclined to give Jackson 2 instead of one. I could also see Hardwick recognising Davey's input and influence, yet Bailey may not of seen Davey at the level he is probably used to. As I said, it's at a guess, nothing else. I could well have it the other way around.

I quite like analysing the votes and breaking them down. I recall analysing Malthouse's votes earlier in the year and it was determined that he didn't give any of his players votes, just by breaking the votes down.

* Reading what they've stated post game may also give some indication.

I agree that Bailey wouldve given votes to Scully, but I actually think he'd have given 5 to Dunn.

(remembering that the bottom pair are interchangeable).

Kicking 5 is great, but shutting down Deledio's drive helped us greatly also.

I think Dimma would have awarded 5 votes to Frawley for nullifying his entire forward line (Riewoldt).

Edited August 10, 201015 yr by E25

I think Dimma would have awarded 5 votes to Frawley for nullifying his entire forward line (Riewoldt).

Ha. I like it !

Melbourne v Richmond

9 James Frawley (Melb)

8 Lynden Dunn (Melb)

7 Brad Green (Melb)

3 Daniel Jackson (Rich)

2 Aaron Davey (Melb)

1 Tom Scully (Melb)

Looking at it like that we really should have won by 10 odd goals.