After the start Scully & Trengove have had I will confidently declare that our top two picks are at the moment a will be throughout their careesrs vastly better players than the much heralded Carltank duo.

Based on their total of 5 career games, i'd have to concur with you good sir!

I think it will be pretty close. Trengove and Gibbs are similar sorts of players... although it took Gibbs 2-3 years before he started dominating games. Trengove is pretty much doing it already (IMO best on ground last night). Both classy players.

Scully and Murphy are different types of players. Murphy is an absolute gun, but I just love Scully. As I said in the other thread he just moves and takes the game on like a young Chris Judd. I think he'll turn out better than Trengove and be an elite midfielder in a couple of years.

Pretty close comparison but I'm stoked with Scullgove!!!

Early indicators have Melbourne a long, long way in front.

Trengove and Gibbs are similar sorts of players...

Trengove is much tougher than Gibbs. He's also having a much better first year - even if it is only 5 games in.

Edited April 25, 201015 yr by Hannabal

Too early to tell, just like it is too early to tell if Watts is better than NicNat.

Too early to tell, just like it is too early to tell if Watts is better than NicNat.

But you know he is don't you.