My 3 word player analysis V The Rats

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

If you were there, you would have seen that he didn't care.

If he cared he wouldn't have been jogging around in circles with his hands in the air calling for the ball.

You did not have to been there to form Nasher's opinion. The fact you go to the game but still hold that naive impression says alot.

Its ridiculous to allege that he or any player does not care.

Its a pity the game has passed him by. It should be his last AFL game.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Bartram - Never looked good

Bate - Lazy, lazy, lazy

Bruce - The sideways specialist

Buckley - Glimmer of hope

Carroll - Not to blame

Dunn - Harvey was right

Frawley - Surprisingly better performance

Green - Barely even noticed

C.Johnson - Never got going

P.Johnson - Needs better presence

Jones - Low on confidence?

McDonald - Kept on battling

Maric - The shining light

Martin - Keeps on impressing

Morton - Give him time

Sylvia - Just about gone

Warnock - Not to blame

Wheatley - Just foats around

Whelan - Surprisingly bad disposal

White - Last ever game

Valenti - Glimmer of hope

Wonaeamirri - Does something everytime

[Jaded No More 68,867]

You did not have to been there to form Nasher's opinion. The fact you go to the game but still hold that naive impression says alot.

Its ridiculous to allege that he or any player does not care.

Its a pity the game has passed him by. It should be his last AFL game.

IMO the ability is still there, but the desire is gone.

Maybe I'm wrong, but when a player doesn't go in for the tackle, doesn't run those extra few steps and doesn't chase, but basically stands still when the ball is not in close vicinity, they just don't care anymore.

That doesn't mean they don't care about the club, it simply means they are tired of playing the game at the highest level and that the motivation to keep going is no longer there. Knowing you have 3 games left (if that) is certainly not helping the situation.

As I said, I admire White for everything he has done for the club (through some horrific injuries) and it saddens me to see him leave the game on such a poor note.

[beelzebub 23,313]

That doesn't mean they don't care about the club, it simply means they are tired of playing the game at the highest level and that the motivation to keep going is no longer there. Knowing you have 3 games left (if that) is certainly not helping the situation.

BINGO..It really takes the edge and urgency off. Probably not even intended..it just happens. You know the end is nigh...and it just kills the moment.

I dont really understand why he was on the park.

[Demon16 69]

I dont really understand why he was on the park.

fair call. those that have seen more of sandy than i would know better, but i'm not sure he did anything to justify a return. then he again he might still have been our only option to replace jamar.

[kramer 0]

carroll is finished.

was ok on Mooney i thought.

[kramer 0]

it was a shyte slippery night, skills are going to be down especially young blokes skills

nothing wrong with Geelongs skills <_<

[astrodee 0]

was ok on Mooney i thought.

Sure was - until he took Mooney the guy was beaten. He played him back to form.