Earl Hood

13 minutes ago, TeamPlayedFine39 said:

Barty’s through!!

Not without a few frights for heaven’s sake! But she got there! 

10 hours ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

Yes. As a golf pro said to me regarding my multi flawed technique - " Practice makes permanent"

Yes Uncle I know what your saying. I stopped playing golf about 10 years ago after a year of intensive faulty practice that ingrained a slice off my tee shot and the next approach shot, basically my game was shot. Thus the use by many golfers of a swing doctor to detect any changes in their swing that may lead to errors under the pressure of competitive play. Is set shot goal kicking similar in that kicking techniques can change slightly without the player realising and suddenly, a la TMac, they can’t kick straight? I think so, thus my query about the lack of review of goal kicking technique by our key forwards. Yes they may kick freely at practice but freeze up, tighten up in a game and hook the ball off line.  

golfers have to deal with this to make a living, how to make the clutch putt on payday. They have to stay loose and go through their routine and not think of the consequences of failure. 

4 minutes ago, Gorgoroth said:

Sure you can, but as the greats have said (Dunstall being a main one) what you practice is what you revert to in game. 

Otherwise why train anything ever.

Yes the great forwards talk of developing a technique and a routine that stands up under pressure. Professional golfers all have a repeatable putting routine, so it should be for set shots for goal. Practice makes perfect they say! As long as you practice the correct technique of course. 

34 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

How does Kyle Dunkley look on the track?

I didn’t know his number so couldn’t pick him out. At one stage I thought I was watching him but that turned out to be Lockhart. 

1 hour ago, buck_nekkid said:

Did Hore and Salem train?

Salem trained the whole session and was involved in everything but I don’t remember seeing Hore now that you mention it. 

Got to training late this morning.

Petty was walking off to the rooms early;

didnt sight Lever, nor Angus, Viney or Lewis;

competitive drills where they had to clear the ball from a stoppage and get the ball to an outside runner who would deliver a pass to the leading forward coming out of the goal square, closely checked by a defender. Pruess vs May for much of the drill. Does that mean anything? 

May trained strongly, Oscar B was impressive in a contested drill where you had to work the ball through heavy traffic, get the ball to a coach and then try to smother his kick. Got the smother in everytime. 

While the key backs practiced punching high ball kicked into Rawlings with a pad on his back, the others did a session of goal kicking. It seemed to be just a free for all of set shots and snaps, no inkling of any coach working on set shot technique! I haven’t seen anyone working with our key forwards on technique and routine etc. must be old school. I watch Weid out 2 ones straight through from 45 dead in front, no issues there at practice but game day....

and watching the key backs in the punching drill there was no emphasis on punching the ball to the boundary side on the contest. They got complimented whether they punched it inboard or straight ahead...again I must be old school, (where is Anthony Ingerson these days)? 

That was about it for observations.

Anyone know if we have engaged a specialist goal kicking coach yet? You know someone who might be able to improve technique and develop routines (that allow players to replicate that technique in all circumstances)for set shots! Goal kicking has cost us 3 games this season. 

Petracca is a classic case study, his ball drop on a set shot inside 45m can do anything with him often spinning the ball in his hands just prior, to stay loose I suppose? 

6 Gawn

5 Oliver

4 Brayshaw

3 Jones

2 Viney

1 Frost

Can’t kick goals

end of story

3 minutes ago, samcantstandya said:

He only had 6 possessions last week. This week he kicked a couple but it's what he misses and doesn't do that irks me. He doesn't go when it's his turn. Gee compare him to Viney or Hunt who get clobbered. I'd trade or delist him he is 2 flakey

In fact I'd get rid of JKH 2 he gets very nervous when he thinks contact is coming his way. Although strangely he loves 2 tackle. OMac either is tried as a forward or goes in2 the gym he gets ragdolled far 2 much.

 

JKH first game this year after extended injury, love your empathySam. 

6 minutes ago, At the break of Gawn said:

I don’t like player bashing but he is the definition of a liability.

Some of his defensive efforts on Jenkins were woeful.

Had 2.3 kicked on him, yes that was the difference, NOT. 

7 minutes ago, Farmerjeff said:

Oscar had a goal kicked on him in the most critical part of the game when he was laying a full tackle on Jenkins. Only Oscar

 

Jenkins is big unit but I am sure you would have brought him down. We lost it in front of our own goal. 

1 minute ago, nichoneitz said:

Delist Oscar McDonald and Jeff Garlett now.

Oscar had 2 goals kicked on him, not a great game but really. We lost it up forward, set shots missed, Max, Hunt, Smith, Weid, then dropped chest marks, Jeffy, the list goes on. The Crows had half the opportunities but nailed most of them. If you can’t finish you can’t win, it is that simple. 

If you can’t kick set shots from inside 40m what about 5 times in a match you cannot win! 

Umpires nearly gifted qCrows a goal there, not 15, play on for no reason leads to turn over. 

Looks like the Viney of Old so far. 

9 minutes ago, Demon Disciple said:

Yep, been better than the likes of Spargo, Stretch and Hannan.

I was thinking Stretch was playing a role in defence and on the wing rather well. But there you go. 

How many so called holding frees can the crows be given? 

Razor keeping the Tigers in the game I see. Is he a club member? Push in the back by Dusty, not paid, goal. Not Late bump paid for a goal, incorrect disposal on Cochin, not paid. Go Ray! 

We cant win a free but still goal

Throw and goal to WC why bother with rules? 

That was nearly a goal to the umpire

Umpires making things difficult so far with separate interpretations of holding the ball for each team! 

Scrapping the barrel here I fear. Neither Oscar or Harrison have done enough consistently at VFL level to warrant a call up. But these are desperate times so let’s hope they put in blinders or at least contribute. 

It was a jumping head shepherd two weeks in a row. Similar to jumping up a goal post. Nothing reportable here.