Straight Sets Simon

I'll be shocked if Bugg gets a second chance.

I'd move him back to the backline to replace Lewis with Jones back in the middle.

I didn't see the Casey practice game, I've only seen the match report so hard to say with great confidence who deserves to come back in.

The chase and tackle his highlight of the night, last week he didn't look like even thinking about laying a tackle. He still can't kick for goal further than about 35 metres out which a big concern. His kicking action just has no power to it.

Good call on McDonald, another week where he kept his opponent very quiet.

Out: Bugg, Harmes, Wagner, Lewis No idea who comes in at this stage, our depth being good is a myth. Bugg was diabolical. Harmes has been completely ineffectual. Wagner wasn't so bad later in the game but we need probably Frost to take one of Brown or Waite to free up Lever. Lewis has become a liability.

6. Garlett 5. Hogan 4. Oliver 3. Jones 2. Fritsch 1. Petracca

Ten goal win was par for the opposition and to choke like that 42 points up is unforgivable. Bogey performance overall.

Hunt has regressed.

Selfish, Melksham.

Garlett best on, Hogan needed that after failing to make the distance from 30 metres. Still need another couple of goals.

We need another five goals now, bury them.

These umpires are as bad as Melbourne.

Good to see Garlett come back for the final quarter.

Two Melbourne players fly for the same ball, no one stays down. Why is this still happening?

Hogan’s goal kicking is no good further than 30 metres out.

It turns out it was the third quarter. Dumb free kicks, lazy fumbles, overusing the ball in contested situations and poor skills.

Any team five goals down against Melbourne is a chance.

We should be ten goals up.

Lewis fumbling the ball started this.

Bloody fumbles!

Overusing the ball in contested situations.

Tyson holding the ball?

If Hogan didn’t wear a circus tent for a jumper he wouldn’t get grabbed so often.

Lazy marking efforts.