Deefiant

Pretty obvious you dont watch much of GC if you think May is similar to Pederson. Theres no way GC would accept a 2019 first round pick as they would get a higher pick if they let him go for free agency. They only way a deal would be completed is if they got a high draft pick this year.

Id say it would probably be the security of a 3 year contract. Cant see us offering close to that

I think we should focus on the inconsistent players on our list (Petracca) before we try to grab inconsistent players on other lists and make them guns

Just wanted to send some brayshaw love. Thought he was really important last night. Mightve been a coincidence but when he went off with the knock the hawks were all over us. He comes on gets that scrappy kick to set melksham up.

Coming from interstate and would love an extra barcode. Happy to return the favour and give my barcode away in later weeks (maybe not the grand final if we make it)

I defended you when everyone was attacking your unpopular opinions about Gaff yet here you are attacking someone for expressing their opinions on a player. Its a forum where people are free to express what they want. Just because you don't like it doesnt mean he doesnt have a right to express it.

If that does occur I bet the hawks and sydney will draw so we finish 5th anyway

Did you listen to Gus on the AFL exchange. He was [censored] and rightfully so. I would expect there would be a fair few issues that need to be worked through if mfc was to offer Gaff a contract

Hodge and Mitchell both had success with the Hawks. Jones has stuck with us through the worst period and should be there to enjoy the good times. Loyalty works both ways. If he wanted a big payday he wouldve left ages ago.

Pretty embarrassing thread. You'd think that after the period we've been through there would be some humility in supporters. But no let's lay into 60 and 40 goals per year forwards who have achieved more than any of our current forwards have.

Crawford said that Maxy was crook during the week.

On the afl exchange podcast he said he was confident on getting the deal done and that his preference was to stay at Melbourne. Raises a little bit of doubt rather than the when, not if...

To me his clearly talking about our training pitches/conditioning program rather than the pitches we use 4 days of the 40 something weeks they work on.

Your correlations you "can't ignore" are about as useful as saying injuries are occurring around the time we play at the G

Seems to make sense. Does that mean in the case of Sloane they wouldnt have to since technically he just extended his contract?

Pretty sure this is wrong. The commentators are talking about how much money hawthorn have in their salary cap because of cyril retiring (contracted until 2020). The afl didn't make a ruling they just said you would have to because it was such a big contract not sure how they would go about following through with their threat if he did retire.

Unless theyre going to switch someone else from the inside to the outside. His two games on the outside have been very disappointing

Salem signed up a couple of weeks ago

http://www.tas-cas.org/fileadmin/user_upload/Arbitral_Award_WADA_ESSENDON.pdf It says that melksham is suspended until 13th of november, but can start training two months before