Steve13

When Mitch either returns to us or does the right thing by us ie. agree to a trade, a lot of demonlanders will need to have a good hard look at themselves. The disgusting vitriol shown here is an indictment on our club and the majority of supporters. Based on nothing but speculation from journos who have repeatedly been discredited and chastised on this very forum, many have chosen to attack personally a man who is suffering a mental illness. Get a grip!

All going very early, I'm yet to see a quote from either Mitch or his manager re: not playing with us.

Roos had breakfast with him this morning.

Tweeted by Robbo.

Well done to them all especially Bail. He has turned it around this year and all credit to him.

As for Terlich, you can't delist them all and he is one that can count himself as slightly lucky. Ball is squarely in his court now.

Jetta Mcdonald Dunn

Grimes Garland Malcevski*

Michie Viney Toumpas

Vince Hogan Howe

Watts Dawes Mitchell*

Gawn Tyson Jones

int. Sam Reid* Petrecca* Salem Trengove

assumes

#2 Petrecca

Swap #3 and priority #21 to Swans for Reid and Mitchell

Pick #42 Stretch ( father/son)

Swap #60 for Malcevski

Get this done and I'll be very, VERY, happy

Today was awful, but not as awful as it was for Jonno Patton. Puts it all into perspective. Good luck to the young man, I hope he comes back bigger and better than ever.

I am doing my Honours year as a history student, Tony is my supervisor. I spoke to him yesterday and he gave me a sneak peak at the article. He is really passionate about both footy and baseball and wrote this with nothing but the best of intentions re the Dees. He really believes that we could facilitate this partnership and bring the Red Socks to Melbourne.

That's ok we can disagree.

Go to footywire and compare Watts's stats at 23 to many of the now stars of the comp when they were 23 and I think you will be surprised.

because he hasnt shown any capacity to be SOLID !!!

I think his year has been solid. With the continuing improvement that this 23 year old, I repeat 23 Year old has shown under Roos, I have little doubt he will be a very solid player for many years to come.

When we have so many sub standard players on our list why would we trade a bloke who clearly has the attributes to be a solid 250 game player. Until we have 30+ AFL standard player on our list Watts stays.

Clint Jones?

Story in the Age today.

Has put off all contract talks until the end of the season.

We could organise a trade of late draft picks so as to not effect our FA compo pick.

Vardy is a future star. Before doing his knee he was the preferred ruck/forward by the length of the strait. The cats aren't letting this kid go anywhere. Once he gets a clear run everyone will see the talent this kid has.

I popped into the Cattery yesterday to grab my first look at Billy live.

There is no way he will slip to us for a third round pick. We would have to trade our second round pick for this to be possible.

The kid is a gem. Quick, poised, evasive and a good ball user.

What I was most impressed in was his ability to gut run both offensively and defensively. He covers the ground really well and ran arch to arch all day. He finds ways to involve himself in play through hard work and no shortage of smarts.

He drifted forward and took a great contested mark, finishing with a goal, he ran the wings aggressively, providing run and involving himself in many rebound 50s.

There seemed to be a very low stoppage count throughout the game, the few he was involved in he set up aprox 5-10 meters off the stoppage so as to best utilise his pace.

Over all I was very impressed with his game. He will be a ripper and well worth a second round pick.

Caleb Daniel may be tiny, but gee he can play.

Was he wearing the 1 ?

If he stays I will be very happy, he has proven that he can be a star. He would be clearly an important part of our back 6 into the future.

If he goes and we can use the compo pick to gain an A grader through the draft or through another Tyson type trade, I will also be very happy.

I fail to see any down side for us.

The fact that we, myself included, are lamenting the fact that Cross is out for a month shows how far we still have to go as a football cub.

Cross has been nothing short of fantastic this year. His defensive efforts and work rate are second to none. The fact remains however that we are reliant on too few and our depth includes players that will not be on the list long term.

I look forward to the day when we have a group of young, highly rated and deserving players occupying position 23-30 on our list, with the remaining spots filled by project and depth players.

I am very much of the school of thought, unlike previous years, of having full faith in the coaching staff and their decision making come selection time. Based on the trend of the year I see there being minimal changes this week.

Terlich will play as flagged by Roos and the other inclusion will be the player that the coaching staff best believe can fill the role required. Yes this may include players that we here consider 'not up to AFL standard', however we must trust, that strange as it seems, the selection committee know more about what's required than us.

Whoever makes the final 22 has a real opportunity. With a depleted Dogs outfit we can exact revenge for the poor showing earlier in the year. Dees by 15.

From what I've read, Mitchell leaving Sydney would be like Viney leaving Melbourne.

Although not getting a game right at the minute, Mitchell is a swan through and through and is vey much in the future plans for Sydney.

Cant see him leaving.

Great read, great man.

I think I speak for us all when I say, thank you!...and keep it up.

http://m.heraldsun.com.au/news/melbourne-players-speak-of-influence-new-coach-paul-roos-has-had-on-them-and-playing-group/story-e6frf7jo-1226947421559

Serious question Steve why is a left handed one any more beautiful than a well played right handed one?

Surely a good kick is a good kick no matter what foot it comes from!

It just seems to look more natural, fluent, even effortless

What is it about left foot kicks that make so many of them look sublime?

(It's possibly not even backed up statistically, but it just seems there are so many who have this liquid style which isn't seen as often in right foot kicks).

Same with Cricketers, a left handed cover drive is a thing of beauty.

Congats to Spencil and the club. For any one who wants to question list management decisions, just remember Paul Roos is in charge and we should all bow to his superior knowledge and judgment. In Roos we trust.

Well done Jake.

McDonald - Cloke

Dunn - White

Garland - Elliot

Howe - Goldsack

Jetta - Fasolo (most dangerous small)

N Jones - Pendels

Cross - Beams

Tyson - Macaffer (I think this is what Bucks will do)

Grimes - Young (Young is playing the distributer role, Grimes to play defensive forward)

Dawes - Frost

Pederson - Keefe

Frawley - ?

I think we have the tools in the back half to cover them.

The midfield battle will be fascinating and will be where the game is won and lost.

We may be able to stretch them forward of centre.

A few more marks and Goals from the big Russian and I agree, he will be back in AA contention

I would give Grimes or Terlich a defensive forward run with role this week on Clint Young. He was the pies distributer on Friday night, set up a lot of play from half back.