It is unfair.
Unfortunately, first impressions are hard to shake.
Watts was a young kid way out of his depth. Hurley imposed himself with his bigger body kicked a few timely goals and got a back page article labelled 'NEXT BIG THING'
Once some of the media have labeled you awesome the rest of the sheep will follow and it takes ages to change that constantly reinforced view.
I've said it many times. Hurley is hugely overrated. It's not that he is no good. Far from it. It's simply that his reputation got blown so far out of control from an early stage.
In saying that, he has had niggling injuries over the last few years. He is better than he is currently playing.