binman

I very much doubt it. Looked completely at sea tge frw times he racked last season.

I can't see Reid staying at the Eagles. Leaving aside the go home factor, they are years away from being a genuine flag contender. Arguably the tigers are closer given their incredible bounty of top end draft picks. Maybe he says, come with me boys, I'll take you on my back to the promised land. But I think it's more likely he'll leave when his contract is up for a Victorian club that is the premiership window. If so, it could be a win win for the Eagles like the Judd - Kennedy scenario as, assuming no injury issues, clubs will pay through the nose for him - and for good reason, kid is a genuine star (though given how AFL ready he was physically, he's pretty close to his ceiling already I reckon- a bit like Ollie Wines when he was drafted). On Kennedy, I just checked the Eagles all time goal kicking list. Incredibly he is leading it by 199 from Darling and 200 from club legend Peter Sumich.

The best kick in the draft someone said I think. XL's leadership was obviously a huge plus fir rhem, unsurprising given we've lost gus and nibbla. But what I found really interesting was Taylor's comment that XL connected with everyone, 'including staff' etc. That sounds very much like gus. Every organisation needs such people.

Well, they wouldn't want to have rely on the Demon shop. They'd have to find it for starters.

He has played 16 AFL games and was an emergency for the Lions' GF side.

Their footy career might go 12 years if they are lucky. If they are even luckier, their post playing stud career might go 50 years. We might have langfords and Lindsay's running around in red and blue for the next 100 years!

Sharp to the wing? Can't see that personally. The more likely role I would have thought is a direct replacement for nibbla. The wing role is very similar in terms of arc to arc running, but is much more offensive, particularly the opposite wing to Langdon, who has been more defensive than most wingers. If Sharp went to the wing he'd be replacing Windsor, who was much more offensive than langers and was an important element in our attacking transition and how we entered our 50 Does Sharp have the right set of skills to replace Windsor? And if there's any thought of XL going to the wing when he eventually comes into the side it doesn't make much sense for Sharp to warm his spot. Better for him to play HHF from the get go and make the role his own. I suspect, given Bowser told me at training that he might get some wing time, he's a more likely candidate to play on the wing in the first third of the season.

Sad? Tragically, Black Caviar died a couple of months ago But in any case im hoping Langford and XL are champion colts rather than champion mares and throw hundreds of father son/daughter winners after their career finishes.

Agree sharp is leading the race for nibbla's role. But an upgrade on nibbla? Please. Nibbla is a premiership player who has played 176 AFL games, and has barely missed a game in 4 seasons. Finished third in the bluey this year, his third top ten in a row. Sharp on the other hand couldn't get a regular game at the lions, only playing 16 games in four seasons. Nibbla was a best 22 lock who left for family reasons. Sharp left the lions because he couldn't get a regular game. The crows were prepared to give up pick 28 for nibbla. We gave up pick 49 for Sharp. I'll concede sharp has plenty of upside, and may well get to nibbla's level, and hopefully surpass it. But there's no guarantee he will, and at ths point he is certainly no upgrade.

Brain don't fail me now.... I think i'll stick with the somewhat ironic (given his size) XL

Yep, agree. Though his technique is not text book - he has a bit of the tracc high ball drop. But he is often kicking when running flat out, which makes it harder to nail kicks. Very coachable and driven, so I agree he'll improve. Kid is a total gun. Aside from gis obvious talent, he has something else about him too -at the risk of sounding wanky, he has an elite mindset. He will make the most of his talent and improve his game year on year. There was an example of his focus, and the standards he sets for himself in a game at the g, i can't recall which. He missed a set shot with a shank. He had another opportunity from a similar spot and was really deliberate in his set up. Nailed it. The club deserves massive kudos for a rebuild whilst noone was watching. At some point early next season top end draft talent from the last two drafts in the Duke, Kolt, Langford and XL will play together. The last time we had that sort of young talent playing together was tracc (but not 'till his second year because of his acl), clarry, viney and gus a decade ago when we were cellar dwellers. And unlike those four, the new fantastic four are coming into a side that boasts premiership players, players with mutiple AA blazers and a raft of 21 -23 year old guns like koz, jvr, mcvee and Turner (who is my tip for our break out player). Exciting times.

Fair call. Windsor was touted as an elite kick as a draftee. Based on that i was a tad disappointed in his kicking last year.

Agree he's more than a pure winger. And he's not really an outside player as such - too hard at it It's interesting he's spending some time with the defensive unit. Could play as an attacking half back flanker and use both his speed and want for the contest.

I noted in an thread that i hoped goody would ecourage spargo to play with a bit more freedom and creativity. Ditto sparrow. He's always been a role player. I'd like to see how he'd go in a less defensive role.

Lucky the face palm is gone, to be fair. Thumbs down is positively polite.

With his eyes?

Bit of talk previously about clarry being a bit overweight. I wish my overweight looked like his!

In my experience, that is helpful if the activity is listening to Dark Side of the moon. Exercise activities not so much.

Hopefully he gets fit. Last year was a nightmare for him. If he gets his chance I'd like goody to encourage him to play with a bit more freedom and creativity. Make him a permanent old school goal kicking half forward flanker (as opposed to being a nibbla style high half forward) and make his KPIs goal assists and goal.

A gold standard reup. Drop the mic. Elephants and DL posters. Where you been 45HG? Good to have you posting again.

Drives me nut. I reckon another factor is the AFL's desire to have fewer free kicks. Just pay the frees that are there. The players will then adjust.

So we could get both? Kentfield was playing WAFL, which sadly given it was once very strong, is less competitive than the VFL. Better to get Special K into an elite environment and let AJ continue his development in the VFL.

It's awesome isn't it. I love it. And agree it would be a terrific clash option - except against the bombers

Windsor in the main.