-
The Sullivan Robey Thread
To be fair, the championships were pretty ordinary. The top groups has grown (a little) because the eastern boys went on a tear (Taylor x 2, Robey, Greeves, Dova) and they have all moved into first round contention and Grjs played well in the seniors. I don’t think we’ve had anyone else rise up to extend that top group. It’s still not great 😂
-
2025 List and Contract Details
I think you are probably right there. I'm not sure about Sinnema at this point, I hope so as I like him, but I think that's probably on the money.
-
AFL Trade Radio 2025
Morris has said that it’s unlikely Melbourne will deal 24, more likely a later pick. could be a pick we get for Clayton. So could look worse - Trac and Clayton for 7 and 8.
-
Potential Father Son Prospect Noah Yze
We have 4, could be 7 spots available (Trac, Oliver, Woey [OOC]) so who knows. We need to get players from somewhere and it isn’t a deep draft class. My educated guess would be train on spot in summer for a SSP position.
-
The Latrelle Sumner-Pickett Thread
Seems about right at the moment. Depends how he tested in the combines.
- The Toby Sinnema Thread
-
2025 Player Reviews: #12 Koltyn Tholstrup
Wow.... Really? Really? That is your takeaway from the 2 years he has been on the list. That he is lazy, sits in cafes, doesn't listen to coaches, and he must have got a rocket at the exit interview? Tearing up the track in pre-season, track watchers getting excited, then gets injured and has to work his way back to fitness. So has not had any pre-seasons. Then in the back half of the year, leads the Casey midfield, breaking tackles, getting clearances, setting up goals. But because he has a mullet, he must not work hard at all? Maybe someone needs to have a word with him to go find a club where supporters are willing to accept that a human being can be who they are, and still train hard and play good football. I would hate to be the child or employee of half the people on this thread - your self-confidence would be shot and you'd have no chance at being able to make it at anything. There is critical analysis about a player's flaws and areas of improvement, but calling out their dress sense as an example of them not taking their job seriously is low.
- Melbourne NGA prospects
-
2025 Player Reviews: #21 Matthew Jefferson
This - exactly this. He showed enough in Game 1 v GWS and looked good for 30 seconds in Game 2 before going off. When we move the ball well, he will look better because good luck outmarking him when he is leading and the go-go-gadget arms are out.
-
Farewell Judd McVee
Looks like they go nervous and didn't put Trac and Clarry in.... but ended up with McVee and May
-
Farewell Charlie Spargo
Love him. Sad to see him go.
-
End of season 2025 interviews
Can’t remember which journo, but they reported no one asked for a trade.
-
CASEY: RD 18 vs Sandringham
If you look at Jefferson’s scouting reports - he has always had days where he has kicked 2.5 and then 5.2 the next week. If you are looking for reasons to write off Kolt and Jefferson, you can do that today. Easily you could also make an argument that the skills they showed today would translate to 200 game afl players.
-
CASEY: RD 18 vs Sandringham
Doubling that Khalani has barely got a run. Billings has been really good. Kolt around the ball and pressuring but not getting his hands on it since the first quarter - albeit Travaliga has spent more time minding him at stoppage as well. I havent really seen Sharp - yet he has kicked 3! I've liked Kynan Brown today - but I do wonder where he fits in AFL. Mentha so exciting I wish he got it more. I felt deflated throughout the week about Jefferson, but again today you just see how good he can be and that he has all the skills to make it as a top line AFL forward. Thinking towards finals - you'd want to make sure that Kolt doesnt play more than 3 more games in the seniors as it would be good for him to play finals. And oddly Howes will also be avliable for us as well.
-
CASEY: RD 18 vs Sandringham
He better not be, otherwise I'd be angry he isnt playing for us. I love hearing him get the ball!