Mad_Melbourne
Members-
Posts
1,597 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
1
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Store
Everything posted by Mad_Melbourne
-
Masten was my best mid last year, but i thought he would slip further in the draft, enjoy him he will be a 2 goal 25 touch player this year, me thinks
-
Haha I wish I could find a job that easy, applied for 23 once I got my bachelors and decided that I will just do my masters! Only realised that I left the documents up on the work computer, hopefully the boss doesn't check it haha
-
Final instalment I Luv Tingay: Projected Stats Category Highs: 1st in FD Projected Stats Smokey Category: Tackles, I feel that a lot of his players will lay more tackles than what is suggested, and caddy and carazzo are tackling machines usually. This category is one that currently he is 10th in the league, but I feel like this is not an accurate assessment by the projected stats. Depth: Defence Options: 4 Centre Options: 9 Forward Options: 7 Ruck Options: 2 Again as has been the case defence has the least options for this team but the midfield is deep. Although not from dual position players but mainly flat midfielders. Hopefully Leunberger can be injury free and as Zac Smith wont be rushed back by gold coast. Team Overview: Leunberger could well be the best ruckman in the game by the end of the season, if he remains injury free. A strong midfield and the forward line with goal kicking options, but also players who can attract more of the footy instead of just a lump who kicks goals but only had 6 touches. Westhoff may well be a top 20 player by the end of the year if he can continue to rack up good disposal numbers and hit the scoreboard and address his inconsistency issues. I hate Harry O’Brian. Potential Keepers: Pendlebury Westhoff Caddy Mayes How to find him match day: Be the guy in a port jumper hoping boak, butcher and westhoff kill it Scarlett: Projected Stats Category Highs: 4th in Hitouts and FD Projected Stats Smokey Category: Handballs, coming in at 13th with the handball but having a team which consists of some genuine inside midfielders doesn’t make sense. This is the same with the tackle stat, projected stats are very odd, but I think that tackles and handballs are definitely going to be the top categories for scarlett. Depth: Defence Options: 4 Centre Options: 10 Forward Options: 7 Ruck Options: 3 I haven’t really looked into the injury list or suspension list but he has a lot of + next to his players, the problem is the four defenders as he will be two players short for round 1 if they aren’t playing! Midfield depth is apparent and look to all be on the improve aswell. Team Overview: Midfield is a highlight, with lots of these inside midfielders my favourites to watch, most notably Rory Sloane and this is definitely the strength of the team. Drew Petrie and Mayne will also help with the scoring side of things and accuracy aswell due to Mayne finding it impossible to miss a set shot. Defence is the area which it is most shallow, but having everyone back from injury it makes for a strong team. Hoping to see toumpas pushing for selection ahead of shiel, but probably get dual position status mid season. Potential Keepers: Sloane Christiansen Toumpas Shiel How to find him match day: The guy hurling abuse at the fan calling toumpas soft, probably sitting on the north side of the mcg. Galahs: Projected Stats Category Highs: 3rd in FD, 4th in marks Projected Stats Smokey Category: Kicks and Handballs, although in the predicted categories at the moment he sits 6th and 4th his midfield has such strong depth that this is a bit of a lie. Highlighted by Watts predicted 8 kicks a game. Hit outs also especially with Dawson Simpson (IMO) going to be the number 1 ruck at geelong for round 1 at least. Depth: Defence Options: 6 Centre Options: 9 Forward Options: 6 Ruck Options: 2 An even spread of mids and forwards and backs, providing injury cover, the midfield depth will lead to some headaches on the Saturday morning or Friday night depending on when he is locking the team in, due to the amount of first team players that can run throught those 4 midfield positions. Team Overview: A lot of quality midfielders here, but more importantly a lot of midfielders that will play week in week out. He will be hoping the midfield move works wonders for wattsy as that will help with his disposal figures. A side which is dominated by Melbourne players usually has not done well in ultimate footy, but now with the high possession game style this could be the year to have as many as possible (especially on the back of watts, jones and trengoves pre season.) Every year Stephen hill is said to be ready to explode, and he could well be putting himself ahead of Danyl Pearce this year. Potential Keepers: Cotchin Kennedy Matera Lynch How to find him match day: The person heavily encouraging watts and jones to continue running past for the cheap stat of a free kick or mark. Wreckers: Projected Stats Category Highs: 2nd in Handballs, 3rd in FD Projected Stats Smokey Category: Kicks, there is a clear preference for his players to kick the football, lots of them doing more of the outside midfield stuff. Although he is ranked 5th for kicks, could see this being a key area that he will be aiming at week in week out. Defence Options: 3 Centre Options: 11 Forward Options: 10 Ruck Options: 2 3 defenders leaves the depth in this area uite short, although all 3 defenders played basically every game last year, meaning it would not have been an issue for him. Has a love for the dual position centre/forwards. Team Overview: Strength through disposal numbers in the front and mid levels of the ground, not a particularly high scoreboard side, but kicks, handballs and tackles will be the goal from players spending large amount of time through the midfield. An injury free Higgins and Rioli could be the two players that really push this team into the final 8 as they are both capable of score board and decent disposal numbers. Surprise pick of the draft Dean Towers, interesting to see whether he gets a game (maybe some inside word here.) Potential Keepers: Steven Beams Crouch O’rourke How to find him match day: The guy genuinely happy when deledio rips us a new one as usual. Hurricanes: Projected Stats Category Highs: 3rd in FD Projected Stats Smokey Category: Score, he is currently sitting 9th on his score, but his forward line has huge fire power and his midfielders are good for 1-2 goals a game. This means that the predicted 59 is probably a bit under the odds especially with a fit Taylor Walker. Marks with his defenders having a penchant for intercept marks and key marking forwards his marks are likely to increase from 10th on the predicted charts. Depth: Defence Options: 5 (1 is jail bait) Centre Options: 8 Forward Options: 7 Ruck Options: 2 Pretty standard spread of players, with most of the players being one position players which only limits the possibilities of the team he can play not his depth, but has plenty of cover for each position. Team Overview: Another team with a good mix of developing players that will continue to improve, already established players and power forwards. Darling, Walker and Podsiadly will provide the team with a high score and mainly kick the football as well. Hoping everyone can come back from injury and stay on the track will be important for the teams development. Probably has a spare key forward that could attract a trade if all 4 are on the park. Potential Keepers: Griffin Thompson Viney Wines How to find him match day: May not be at many games, but down in echuca on the river with wines and viney. OMR: Projected Stats Category Highs: 1st in score, 2nd in tackles, 3rd in kicks Projected Stats Smokey Category: Kicks, would only be third in kicks because of Sucklings projected stats. Hit outs, Minson will usually beat most other one ruckmen ran sides. Depth: Defence Options: 5 Centre Options: 8 Forward Options: 7 Ruck Options: 2 A decent spread for the team, the only place it could be found short is in the ruck stocks if minson gets injured or suspended, as I doubt Daw will play much. Several key forwards mixed with a few more possession getting forwards which is why the forward line is so strong. Team Overview: In the forward half there are developing youngsters but also some important key position players. Although reports are that Sylvia is in doubt for round 1 due to form, if he is able to produce the form we know he is capable of in a better team it adds to the dynamic of this forward line. The midfield is probably one of the strongest and when Swallow returns the midfield choice is going to be tough. Defenders could be the weakest point but if Frawley plays as a rebounding defender again this team will be hard to stop. Potential Keepers: Swan Hannebery Boyd Patton How to find him match day: The guy annoyed when Frawley is asked to play a lock down role on Nick Riedwolt. 7_UP: Projected Stats Category Highs: 1st in %, 1st in FD, 1st in Hitouts Projected Stats Smokey Category: Score, he is only 13th, but with the amount of key forwards in the line up the score will be much higher, Waite, Pavlich and Cox can all hit the scoreboard. Tackles, he is fourth for tackles, but Liberatore, Ward and Selwood will keep the tackle number up week in week out. Depth: Defence Options: 5 Centre Options: 7 Forward Options: 8 Ruck Options: 3 Probably the strongest ruck line up, once maric returns especially. Otten might be a player to keep an eye out as if he plays forward could chip in for a couple goals. Injury cover all over the field, with depth in each position. Team Overview: The ruck strength of this team is probably the strongest in the league, especially seeing as Cox can end up with numbers of a rover. The midfield has depth and is ridiculously strong with the first 4 being in the top 70 of ultimate footy. Hoping his forward half are able to all stay fit/not suspended as they all missed significant time last season and even over the preseason, as there is an obvious difference with a player like Puopolo on the field instead of Goodes or Pavlich. Jake Melksham was my smokey of the draft and I put him off by one pick and it meant you picked him up, I think he could be a top 70 ultimate footy player by the end of the year. Potential Keepers: Liberatore Selwood Ellis How to find him match day: The person frustrated when Jarrad Grant doesn’t get picked due to poor form and Crameri playing solidly. M_M: Projected Stats Category Highs: 2nd in Score, 2nd in %, 4th in FD Projected Stats Smokey Category: Score and kicks are my best categories, but im hoping due to the way the midfield plays now days I can get a few marks aswell. Depth: Defence Options: 7 Centre Options: 9 Forward Options: 8 Ruck Options: 2 I was conscious of forward and back depth this season, mainly with dual position players as I was often without a good player to play in a position last season. Team Overview: My backline is pretty strong, but because of this I didn’t use any of my early picks on plain midfielders which could be my downfall. I took a bit of a punt on Duncan early, but I am hoping he is the big improver for the year and crashes into the top 50. Have 3 talls and other mid/fwds, if Clark is fit it will add to my selection problems as I think I only really want to play 2 tall forwards. Potential Keepers: Franklin Duncan Hombsch How to find him match day: Im the bloke who has way too much time on his hands So my boss will officially hate me after i have spent my 8 hour shift organising tables on the stats and ranking them from 1-16 whilst checking out everyones list. I have established that it looks to be a competitrive season this year but like the AFL season, the premier from last year has performed well during the preseason and despite a few player movements look quite strong leading into the season.
-
So my boss wont be stoked with my work so far today, but i hope you guys are: 8 teams so far will finish the rest by end of shift Disclaimer: it is all my opinion (so dont hate me) Jarkas Jokers: Projected Stats Category Highs: 3rd in league %, 1st in league FD Projected Stats Smokey Category: 7th for score, but having Tomahawk, Jeremy Cameron, Ballantyne, Dal Santo, Murphy, Lewis and more midfield time for Gibbs, the score category for Jarkas Jokers could some weeks easily break the 100 points. Depth: Defence Options: 5 Centre Options: 8 Forward Options: 7 Ruck Options: 3 From a depth view an injury or two in defence could push the list, but that is why we have 35 trades. Hopefully no niggling injuries leading too 1 or 2 players missing a couple weeks, making trade decisions difficult. Team Overview: From my initial thoughts he has gone down a depth with youth, this will be great in a keeper sense, and players like Macrae and Tyson have had stellar pre seasons which lead to great options on the bench. Murphy could well end up being a top 10 player and Lynden Dunn could be a steal as we all know Melbourne use the footy from our back half through him at all oppourtunities. Look for Blicavs to get a position of defender added throughout the season. If these younger players come on as expected Jarkas Team will be much more solid, with a few selection headaches. The first of which I think will be Macrae vs Ballantyne and could even be Martin. Potential Keepers: Murphy Gibbs Martin Cameron How to find him match day: Jarka will be the guy encouraging dunn to play on from kickouts in order to register a stat. Jakovich Forever: Projected Stats Category Highs: 2nd in Marks, 4th in Score and Kicks. Projected Stats Smokey Catregory: Not so much a smokey Category, but I doubt he will lose marks often with midfielders who have been taking marks often through the preseason and forwards who don’t drop the ball, the mark category for Jako is definitely a strong point. Score is also a category which could rise as his midfielders vince, fyfe and rockliff are dangerous around goals. Depth: Defence options: 6 (1 rookie) Midfield options: 11 Forward options: 7 Ruck options: 2 From the depth chart Vickery is almost his most important player, this is only because Gawn may not be playing much, especially early on, meaning Vickery is important to play week in week out. Then defense could be a little sparse, but if Clisby can bring the form in from the end of last season could be a very smart pick up. Team Overview: Rockliff and Fyfe have the potential to be two top 10 players this year and with Bernie Vinces pre season form the midfield is definitely a dangerous one. Whilst he was disappointed with pulling the trigger so early on Monfries, him and Howe are two players who are pivotal for the teams success, if they are able to push through the midfield a little bit more this season and get their stats up to the 20-23 area with 6-8 marks that will go a long way into ensuring a win for Jakos side. Potential Keepers: Jack Riedwolt Nathan Fyfe Jager O’Meara Lachie Whitfield How to find him matchday: May well be the only Melbourne supporter hoping for an LTI in order to get Georgiou onto the list, although halfway through the season he could well be the nominated rookie anyway. JCB: Projected Stats Category Highs: 2nd in Kicks, 3rd in Hitouts Projected Stats Smokey Category: Tackles, I feel that the players on JCBs team have been underrated on tackles, and whilst he is 7th for the stat in the league, I think it is one that will rise and more often than not he will take out the 3 points. Score is another smokey category due to the option of tippet in the ruck, although the midfield has less scoring potential than other midfields (IMO) Depth Chart: Defence options: 6 Midfield Options: 10 Forward Options: 6 Ruck Options: 3 Ruck depth is a clear strength in JCBs team, with Lobbe and Jamar being 2 number 1 ruckmen and Tippet going to pinch hit, hit outs are a strength. Defensive depth could be the only problem, if Duffield or Enright go down, but Brodie Smith could be a player having a break out season. Team Overview: Stevie Johnson could well be the best ultimate footballer category based player by the end of the season with more time through the midfield and a flat out matchwinner himself. Defense is the only area a little stretched. JCB will be hoping for the midfielders to rack up the majority of his numbers and ride the team to victory off the back of high disposals and from his midfield guns Stevie J, Masten, Stanton, Montagna and Tom Mitchell. Potential Keepers: Stevie J Stanton Mitchell Wingard How to find him on matchday: Asking why Montagna isn’t playing in round 1 and yelling at Jamar to do more around the ground Dark Days: Projected Stats Category Highs: 1st in Marks, 3rd in Score Projected Stats Smokey Category: Hit outs, although he is 5th, his depth in the ruck/forward position will mean that most weeks this category should be one that he wins, especially due to the injury of Maric meaning Hampson will be playing as the number 1 ruckman for the next 6-8 weeks. Depth: Defence Options: 6 Centre Options: 5 Forward Options: 8 Ruck Options: 4 The midfield depth is a bit short, but I feel that bugg will end up being qualified as a midfielder once the first positional additions are out. His ruck and forward stocks are very good, this could well be used to his advantage through trades as rucks are often prone to injury. Team Overview: He will be winning marks, score and hit outs most weeks if everything goes according to plan leading to 9 points and only needing 1 point to win the game. Although his midfield is short, Gary Ablett can often carry teams on his back with a 40 disposal 2-3 goal game and he will be hoping Treloar and Stanley to get heaps of the ball for their respective teams. Potential Keepers: Ablett Gunston Treloar Bugg How to find him match day: Hoping that Frawley, Dunn and Garland are unable to maintain the key forwards, yet we still win the game. RPFC: Projected Stats Category Highs: 2nd in league FD, 3rd in league Tackles Projected Stats Smokey Category: Kicks, although he is projected as 10th in the league for kicks, I feel that players like smith, betts, mcdonald and grundy are under valued in this area, pushing his kick stats up to possibly 4th or 5th in the league. Depth: Defence Options: 4 Centre Options: 11 Forward Options: 8 Ruck Options: 3 From my view his backline depth is the only issue, with Luke mcdonald probably getting the run ahead of grundy, he could struggle with any issues such as suspension or injury, although he has the best defender in the game in Brendan Goddard. Team Overview: Another strong midfield team, if toby greene and lenny hayes have solid seasons it makes the choosing the 4 midfield spots very difficult, and armitage was a steal that low in the draft. The only thing that could lead him to trouble is a heavy reliance on the young defender in Luke Mcdonald, although the guy is going to be a jet, may only play 12-14 regular season games in order to keep him in line for finals. Also Dixon may be player of importance for him for his ability to contribute to so many categories. Potential Keepers: Goddard Sidebottom Mcdonald Hogan How to find him match day: The guy annoyed at Paul Roos as he chose to play Chris Dawes, Mitch Clark and Dean Kent ahead of Hogan and Jay Kennedy-Harris one week. R24: Projected Stats Category Highs: 1st in league, tackles and kicks Projected Stats Smokey Category: Handballs, with a large amount of improving midfielders in the team the ball will be in their hands more. He is already projected to have the highest kicking score but I feel that 5th for handballs is too low and will increase throughout the season. Depth: Defence Options: 8 Centre Options: 12 Forward Options: 3 Ruck Options: 1 His midfield and backline are very well provided, but the fact that there are only 3 possible forwards and 1 possible ruckman leads to the biggest depth issue. If ryder is injured, the team will struggle, luckily his C/F are quite durable players, so far. Team Overview: Very midfield and defence reliant, but lots of his players are younger players in their first few years. This sets him up really well in a keeper position but also in a position that the projected stats will underrate a few of his players. A massive coup for him this year will be Mckenzie playing more time in the midfield allowing him to gain dual position status. A very strong tackling team, and he will be hoping to take out kicks and tackles most weeks. Barlow is probably the most underrated uf player, can kick goals and tackles well. Potential Keepers: Heppell Barlow Kolodjashnij Neale How to find him match day: He will be the guy constantly asking for the scores from other games, checking disposals on the afl app. Range Rover: Projected Stats Category Highs: 2nd in hitouts, 4th in marks Projected Stats Smokey Category: Both the kicks and handballs projected categories seem to be under estimated by the ultimate footy team. With players like selwood only having 24, gaff 19 and zaharakis 22. His kicks and handballs categories will definitely be higher than 9th and 7th. Depth: Defence Options: 6 Centre Options: 12 Forward Options: 5 Ruck Options: 3 Multiple midfield options throughout which is the strength to his depth. Injuries to forwards, mids or backs will not put his team under duress and trading or free agents wont be on the agenda unless there is a major injury. Team Overview: Disposals, disposals, disposals is how I see this team, with all of the midfielders capable of taking a few marks aswell. Aaron Sandilands staying fit will be a massive help to the side, adding hit outs as a category he would rarely lose to a 1 ruck team. David swallow to become a top 50 UF player this year and liam shiels to put the traitor out of the team due to ripper performances. Can dustin martin be allowed to have C/F/D for his positions? Potential Keepers: Martin Selwood Aish Longer How to find him match day: The only person upset when the news that Dustin Martin was found partying with Daniel Connors yet again. snomeD: Projected Stats Category Highs: 2nd in takles and FD, 3rd in handballs. Projected Stats Smokey Category: Kicks, a high percentage of midfielders and dual position players in the team which means that his kicks should be higher than 8th on the list. Probably hoping for mumford to have more than 3 kicks a game! Depth: Defence Options: 3 Centre Options: 15 Forward Options: 8 Ruck Options: 2 The multiple options to run through his midfield means that injury troubles up forward and in the guts will not effect his team. But having an injury to terlich or Mitchell will definitely hinder his performance. Rischitelli will probably get C/F status eventually giving him more options. Team Overview: A good mix of young future keeper options and also younger players who should be pushing up to the top 50 players in the league. Zorko and Bennell will benefit from more midfield time, leading to more disposald and Patty Dangerfield is the number one forward in the competition (possibly by the end of the year number one player, even though I hate him so much). Coniglio, Wright and Rischitelli mean selection dilemmas ahead of Mclean, and there is nothing worse than having better performing players on the bench instead of on the field. Potential Keepers: Dangerfield Bennell Coniglio Daniher How to find him match day: The person most annoyed by terlich running himself into trouble and the only supporter not to boo mclean.
-
had one or two wall punching moments, but overall not to unhappy with my team Defenders: G. Birchall (Hawks) M. Johnson (Freo) J. Hombsch (Port) C. Newman (Rich) Defender/Mids: K. Simpson (Blues) J. Bartel (Geel) S. Burgoyne (Hawks) D. Cassisi (Port) Midfielders: M. Duncan (Geel) D. Jackson (Rich) Midfield/Forwards: D. Thomas (Blues) L. Parker (Swans) V. Michie (Melb) Forwards: M. Clark (Melb) J. White (Coll) L. Franklin (Swans) S. Motlop (Geel) G. Rohan (Swans) Rucks: B. Mcevoy (Hawks) J. Giles (GWS) Pretty happy with the amount of possibilities that i can play over the field, although two injured forwards leaves my depth a little light there, will be interesting to figure out how i line up! i didnt look to see if we have bye weeks off or not, that could be my trouble as i have a few hawks, geelong and swans players
-
I doubt il get onto an actual laptop til like 7:30 was hoping to use my phone for my first couple picks! Just hoping my pre draft settings go okay!
-
Oh shiza! Welllllllll I'm fooked
-
Draft Day is here, hope everyone is ready for the tough season that will be ahead, already in preliminary chats with a few high profile player, all who have declared their want to play under M_M, so lets just allow them their wish and no one draft any of the top 30 players that are available after keepers. Thanks guys
-
id be interested to see the game time stat from Watts on the weekend, i feel like he played only just over 50% of the game and had 22 touches. I very much like how the idea is to get the ball to him as much as possible, i wouldnt be surprised to see him get tagged throughout the year due to the quality of his disposal. The thing i was most impressed with was his determination to try and get the football, especially in the first quarter, he was diving in for the footy a couple times and had a want that i had not seen from him before
-
Dunn has become an asset out of our back half, last season i feel like he was much more disciplined and stuck to his role and although a couple games he did get beat, he was very solid in a defence that had the ball continually flying in. He has a very good ratio of breaking even in one on one contests in the backline, and has the capability of playing tall and small, but his obvious weapon is his disposal out of our back 50. More often than not when he takes the kick out it hits a target and if not it is 75 m up the field anyway, sure he is a bit of a goon and has a knack of getting on everyones nerves, but at the end of the day he is in our best 22 and almost in our top 10 players to be picked weekly.
-
NAB Challenge 2 - Melbourne v Geelong
Mad_Melbourne replied to Whispering_Jack's topic in Melbourne Demons
I think it highlights the mismanagement of players from earlier years also, jkh played a good quarter against the tiges, but still seems to not have the fitness levels to be playing a full game at afl yet! Allowing game time for lots of players is very important and thus spreading the load is vital. Playing Byrnes and blease is probably more about sharing the load. Max king won't play afl level this year but played both games so far so I feel like he isn't against playing youth just wants to keep them fit -
And he will not be playing as a small defender, he is behind Frawley, McDonald, garland and Dunn for the tall defender role
-
Strauss, I personally have Strauss in our back 6. When garland comes back then it makes it tougher because of his ability to play as a small defender. Strauss Frawley Terlich Grimes McDonald Dunn At the moment is my preferred back 6, when garland gets back the situation changes. But I prefer the ball being in the hands of Strauss and Dunn taking kick outs rather than Terlich, even though he kicked a few pearlers
-
NAB Challenge 2 - Melbourne v Geelong
Mad_Melbourne replied to Whispering_Jack's topic in Melbourne Demons
Agree with Byrnes, but he also had 2 direct goal assists from hitting the right spot with kicks I thought watts showed a lot more strength over the football and fight, first quarter was really really solid Tom macs kicking wasn't even that bad, but his shut down job on Hawkins was very good The stutter is a roos directive, hogan stopped going it last year at Vfl level and his goal kicking suffered, if it's comfortable to them then leave it. His around the ground kicking action is more of a swing than a kick aswell. I think people are so over reactive to a stutter if it is comfortable to the player taking the set shot it shouldn't be changed as the change has a negative effect -
Missing Dawes, Clark, Frawley, jamar and garland which is probably our spine and we were able to be competitive all over the field, stoppages and restricting tall forwards. Tom McDonald on Hawkins Midfielders kicking goals 4-5 goals came from turnovers, less goals that come from general play means that we are able to eventually slow the stem of goals from turnovers leading to lower scores kicked against leading to more games won
-
Also buddy looked seriously underdone and parker has an injury to the eye which the extent is not yet known, whoever has them unlucky! edit: ah shiza, thats me edit x 2: great advice for everyone with keepers that are injured, keep them, i did it with my first pick Dale Thomas last year, all season, and he rewarded me with 5 games!
-
The thing that I get confused by is how people say he is poor defensively, i think this is his strongest asset and was probably a reason why when watching him at casey people often said he didnt get enough of the football. He is often too defensively minded and this is why players like terlich and clisby were playing games ahead of him as they are much more noticeable by getting stats. Strauss has all the attributes to be a key small defender for us, but the thing that is best is the kick outs that he did take against richmond were definitely positives out of the square. They dont count in his stats but he also had 20 odd touches, which if it is a sign for things to come he has improved the offensive side of his game. None the less, i really like him as a player, even if it is for depth (at worst case) and would rather him keep a spot on the list for the next 3 years, than replacing him with someone not as strong yet and not ready for afl
-
Offensively terlich and grimes are better, but terlich always tries to do too much and grimes is prone to turn it over! Strauss defensively is far superior to both these players and his kicking is often better aswell, his problem is he continues to struggle to find the mix between running off and playing defensively! This could have been encouraged by Neeld as I feel he stifled lots of the run out of our back half, but Strauss is highly underrated, and often was providing support and manning tall forwards who were not his direct opponent
-
It's funny how varied opinions of Strauss can be, I thought he was more than solid and defensively is nearly our best small defender
-
Speaks volumes about the quality of my list from last year Will improve..I think
-
Thanks very much I do apologise! Yeh the life of a uni student, 10 weeks of travel has been awesome! Now I'm back and ready for the real deal!
-
Who wanted Paul Roos as coach? Who wanted a board overhaul? Who wanted new coaching staff? Well I guess pledge per win is one way to gain some cash, it's more interesting than tin rattling. I like the idea, whilst I have limited funds and often try to support the club as much as possible, instead of the raffle tickets weekly I prefer this, and it takes a weight off the foundation heros, although I'm sure this year they will be spoken too haha!
-
The injury change was in regards to Thomas, due to him only playing his first game yesterday and continual speculation about his injury status, it was impossible to lock the keeper without the knowledge. I didn't want to be stuck with a keeper who was on the indefinite injury list the whole season Edit: it was immediately after the game he played and it is still a week til draft day, having said that if it is an issue with all, am happy to stick with Masten
-
also, letting everyone know, after much deliberation with the coaching panel of M_M and our new franchise owner, we have decided to offer Dale Thomas the much sought after keeper spot instead of Chris Masten. There will be a press conference later today, but he is very happy to be doning the light blue with red and yellow vs.
-
NAB Challenge 2 - Melbourne v Geelong
Mad_Melbourne replied to Whispering_Jack's topic in Melbourne Demons
it depends how you judge players and obviously on injury aswell. i feel that the only 2 ruckman that cant play together are Spencer and Jamar. i would be happy to see a line up of Jamar and Gawn, Spencer and Gawn, due to the fact that gawn would play as the fwd/ruck. it is nice to have an abundance of talls who i feel are all capable to play respectably at afl level