-
Posts
1,001 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Store
Posts posted by gsmith12
-
-
In my view picks are paper money. You really dont know what you are going to get or the true value of the pick for some time. Sure they are an opportunity to back your guess before other teams but history shows that remains very speculative exercise. Roos knows this when he articulated his general approach to the draft. It appears our approach was to find the best available replacement for Frawley. Our bet is that Frost is developing as a key backman who is not yet as good as Frawley but can fill that role at senior level. If we passed because of some belief that picks are bankable currency then we have learnt very little as a club. The question is not whether he was worth pick 23 but rather does he fill the role we needed to fill this year and we will know the answer over the next season.
Good post and far too much logic for many around here.
-
Oh come on! What else is there to pass the day?
Something productive that does not provide regular let downs ?
I do however get your drift.
-
My brother and I saw it live too, was a coward act. Giles went back on in the forward line after he "recovered" from memory.
Thanks for the pic TSFKA
I vaguely remember Alan Jarrott carrying out some retribution on the thug #3
-
1
-
-
You never really hear anything on these boards about Peter Giles - he looked like a wildman when he first started - he could play though
One of our better players during the Flower era nutbean who suffered nasty achilles and knee injuries which restricted his game tally to 124.
Also another of our boys to be hit from behind by the mongrel thug Matthews.
-
Would that be the Glenn Giles, brother of Peter who played 2 games for us in 1981.
Born the year after Robbie so time frame is right.
-
Memo to self - do not read trade threads in 2015, full of speculation, fantasy and bull.
-
2
-
-
St Kilda will be trying to get this deal done in the next hour.
That way they get first dibs at Frost in the PSD.
Too late she cried.
-
Frost 40 and 53 for 23.
Hmmm
-
Essendon must be trying to gain the oldest list in the business picking up Cooney whom many suggest is cooked.
-
On reflection, some great players have brought fame and honour to the number #11
I speak of Harold Ball, Laurie Mithen, Tony Anderson, Greg Wells, Steven Icke and Jimmy Stynes amongst others.
Sadly, all Clark brought was shame.
-
1
-
-
Mitch Clark: @mitchjclark
Couldn't be more excited to be on board with @GeelongCats I can't wait to get into preseason with the boys #perfectweddingpresent
Crickets...
I read several similarly worded tweets from Clark pre season 2014 to raise my hopes.
Turned out to be disingenuous rubbish.
I wish the Cats and yourself no success.
-
1
-
-
No but Pat Cummings is back.
I see that Pattinson is currently playing for Victoria two's as a batsman and making runs too.
Nice to Cummins back and taking wickets after such a long stint on the sidelines.
-
Anyone have info on the fitness of Pattinson and Siddle ?
-
Extraordinary over from Maxwell even allowing for inept batting from the tail.
-
Thankyou Bernie Quinlan for your wonderful tribute to Robbie Flower.
Coming from a celebrated champion such as yourself means a great deal to to countless Demon supporters.
-
1
-
-
I’ll add my few cents…
possiblyprobably a bit self-indulgent but hopefully that can be excused for an occasional poster in these circumstances.My dad started taking me to the footy in about 1981 when I was 10 and my sister was 8. From that time on we went to nearly all the home games at the ‘G, often to
WaverlyArctic Park, and then as we got older to more and more of the enemy territories (Moorabin, Western Oval including that game in ‘87, and the Junction). So I was fortunate enough to see Robbie play a lot, and he was my hero from Day 1. I think I’ve taken for granted how often I got to see him play, and reading the responses here from the younger members makes me appreciate it more.We lived on the Mornington Peninsula but my dad was originally a Murrumbeena boy and when he was 21/22 and playing for Murrumbeena 1s he also coached the Murrumbeena Districts under 11s, featuring none other than R. Flower.
I live in country NSW now but was visiting my folks this past week while the kids were on school holidays so we did a lot of reminiscing and also a lot of rummaging around in my old bedroom, and this was in the cupboard. It’s hard to see (camera photo) but there are two signatures on the number two: Flower and Barassi. Believe it or not in the pocket was a ticket (booked through Bass!) for the 13th of September 1987 (the flogging of the Swans).
After more digging around we also uncovered the poster that adorned my wall from the mid-80s until I left home (longer really, as I kept coming home to play cricket on weekends, so it remained on display in my room).
Dad has more stuff, a picture of the U11s side, the gift they gave him as coach, a three page fax from Robbie that Paul O’Brien (who taught with dad ) organised when dad finally gave up the teaching game.
Memorabilia aside, my memories of Robbie the footballer are inclined towards hero-worship, no matter what happened he could do no wrong. Watching the old youtube stuff shows things I’d forgotten, or possibly never appreciated, how quick he was, how he routinely made would-be tacklers look silly, how his kicks were low and very penetrating.
It’s horribly sad and my heart goes out to his family.
To complete the loop a little, for me anyway, when I was at Uni I ended up living in Murrumbeena and although I’d been playing Rugby Union while at Uni (more as a drinking exercise than physical exercise) I had a crack at footy for one year because I knew I was moving overseas the next. I played at the ‘Beena, 15-16 very undistinguished games in the Magoos as a ‘determined backman’. Great fun, made great friends and was proud as punch to play at the same club as my dad.
Nice post Ken, I can relate to what you saw of Robbie as I started taking my 4 kids to Demon games in 1982 when I was in Ballarat.
My eldest is your age and he treasures the memories of RF as do my other children.
Sad as you say to see another Demon legend pass.
-
3
-
-
If you are attending the G Jack, say one for me, would love to be in town.
-
Bit of a fizzer this series. Watched a bit of the first two ODI's and I can say it wasn't very exciting at all.
Little wonder the excitment level has subsided when we play so much cricket these days.
Reckon we should dispense with some of the shorter form.
-
Understand the love for Trenners but gee wizz some people need to relax and have a little faith in Roosy!!!
You've hit the nail on the head nuts, the drafting under Roos was top drawer last year and I see no reason why a repeat is not in the pipeline.
-
I understand what you're saying, beelzebub, and I guess you're right. Nevertheless, this one leaves me feeling a little hollowed out.
I share that feeling too ET, spoke to Jack at Princes Park before he went to the games to encourage Jess.
A more humble genuine young fella you will not meet, doesn't win games though.
-
1
-
-
I've read most of this thread but not all so apologies if this has been said.
If I was Trengove's manager I'd tell him to jump at the Richmond offer. Unlike others I'm in the boat that says Trengove is an average footballer never likely to be and A grader. He's a marking small IMO and will struggle to find a role in a team. I've always thought this but was convinced when I sat in the Southern Stand and watched Brock out pace him to a loose ball.
Trengove's initial reaction would always have been to stayed at MFC, he's that sort of bloke, but I think it's in his best interest to leave. If he has an uninterrupted season in 2015 and fails to improve much he's shot in terms of future value. His "blue sky" will have evaporated and his future will be mediocre at best. Those hanging on to the "now he's fit" theory should keep in mind his underwhelming 2012 and 2013.
If he goes to the Tigers he'll get at least a 3 year contract on good coin - they obviously rate him. He'll leave behind toxic memories of mismanagement he endured at MFC and he'll leave behind all the expectations placed on him by us. He'll go to a club that has played finals for two years, he'll be surrounded by much better players and he'll have a longer, better contract.
I have upmost respect for Jack but reality is he's been a bitter disappointment a far as output goes. I hope wherever he ends up he succeeds. But I think it's in his interest to go and in our interest to trade him regardless of whether the trade in part of a "bigger picture".
The heart says a definite no, the head says you may be right assuming of course that the foot wasn't the cause of his ordianry '12/13 seasons.
-
Martin is head and shoulders above most of the journos of today.
Yet another wonderful article.
-
Seems the players are calling the shots at the kennel.
Not good for the game.
-
1
-
-
Not happy with the idea at all and it would give me even more reason to despise the feral Tigers.
WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - SAM FROST
in Melbourne Demons
Posted
You are correct Tim, quite a chuckle particularly the offerings of luminaries like WEERIDEE et al.