old dee

Remember he has not played a game yet.You could just as easily say he is a guy with a very bad back problem who may never play.

The guy played a lot of good games for the MFC and if he made a few mistakes well tough most people do. I find it sad that after the years he put in at the Dees it ends this way. A few on here could be a little more gracious. If I had to choose between him and Neeld it would not be a hard choice.

Casey!

We used to say similar things about Sylvia And it never really happened . For different reasons I fear a similar fate for Watts

Another excellent example of being how good footballer does not make you a rocket scientist.

Good point Bossdog

You had me until the last eight words.This will probably the lowest ratings for Saturday night football this year. Almost everyone will have picked the Swans and watch the movie on nine.

They are not alone WJMost newspapers are a shadow of their former selves. A dieing medium

I can thing of a lot of worse locations. Do they have yum char at lunch time?

Pedersen I am astounded that he has been useful in the majority of games this year. I had VFL branded on his photo but he has actually earned his spot most weeks.

Rarely does getting stuck in make up for a lack of talent Dockett. However if we don't have a red hot go from the start it will be ugly by three quarter time.

I don't think 12 LdvC but I reckon 8 is a real possibility. I watched a little of the Swans/Freo game last weekend we are so far behind those two we cannot hear the band.

The simple fact is that he has a back problem that it would appear is not going to go away any time soon. I really don't care at this point how he got it. He will not be playing any time soon. I worry we may not see him for a considerable time. It is looking like July to me at the earliest. I have all but written him out of any meaningful contribution this year. I hope 2015 is a belter of a year for him.

That may well be rpfc but the look is very familiar

You can think it Ouch after all we are only giving our opinions.There are 16 games to go I hope you are correct but I am not holding my breath.

What were we discussing ?

I would trade tomorrow for a good deal. This is his sixth year on the list. this is as good as it gets What you see is what you get. Every year we all make excuses for him. I have run out the clock is ticking

I have been going to VFL / AFL matches since 1960 and I can guarantee you they were gone as a regularly jumper before then.

Why? The worst player last week after very ordinary games since round 1

That makes two of us GV

Sharp today WJ Razor blades for lunch?

A fate worse than death Redleg.

Agree with all that Redleg you have summed up my feelings exactly. I would only add that I will be very disappointed if he is not dropped this week.

Now are you sitting down dc? I agree with you!

My dad was WW2 Chippy on the Kokoda. On top of that a number of friends went to Vietnam. A couple have never been the same since. Small thing on my part.