Jump to content

whatwhat say what

Life Member
  1. Sigh… not great
  2. "hamstring soreness" or "tight calf" or "general soreness"
  3. he seems so determined to go to the one place, and they don't have the capacity to get the deal done i don't know how, given both player's contracts, you can trade either of them oliver puts in more effort, petracca has greater flexibility to-mato / tom-ato
  4. the issue remains that he is, seemingly, only willing to go somewhere, and that's to the filth i doubt they have anything to offer us, and will make us pay for the privilege of him playing for them
  5. just another 'nothing' footballer good in the vfl; below average in the afl
  6. right, so season officially done time to bring el jefe and adams in at either end sorry melk and may, but old blokes first out
  7. at least he didn't sign up may until 2027
  8. no, but he's been so far behind georgiades since he went on to him at every contest that it's just embarrassing
  9. may has looked so, so slow today
  10. All the commentary so far has him as eligible to be drafted by us as part of our nga
  11. That last comment is a pearler
  12. whatwhat say what posted a post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    he's the future of the forward line for gw$ they will fight tooth and nail to hold onto him - just as they did to secure the #1 pick to acquire him - and he'll be rewarded accordingly
  13. spargo is an unrestricted free agent - if he gets a significant offer from another club, he may elect to leave according to those who know, this upcoming draft is supposedly the weakest in some time - i for one doubt we will be looking to trade into it we have a host of players who have little or no trade value and those that may have value - particularly the wa boys; van rooyen, mcvee, tholstrup, rivers, even adams at a stretch - are those that i would say we can least afford to lose as they should form the basis of our best 23 side for the bulk of the next decade i really, really hope that kalani white picks the mfc to come to as a father-son; his final quarter in his casey debut last night was utterly thrilling to see clearly we will, if things go our way, pick toby sinnema as an nga pick, while our 2026 nga pick marcus prasad looks like an even more exciting option so, 2026 and 2027 first round picks? sell em to flagmantle - i want dogga jackson back likely delisting candidates: billings hore fullarton woewodin henderson culley billings plays a role as a vfl player but should never play for the mfc again - we have better options as a mid rotation - while hore is unlucky that he's out of contract and is constantly injured, while fullarton is just completely uncompetitive possible retirements: melksham plugger mac campbell personally i would keep all three on the list; possibly shift campbell to the rookie list in lieu of verrall or let him retire IF we get dog back from out west trade options: oliver laurie sparrow fritsch i think laurie offers no value to being on the list as a primary inside mid; he should want and demand a trade elsewhere where he can try and get more opportunity at another club - i personally have doubts as to whether he is good enough to make it in that role in an afl team, but he definitely deserves the opportunity i wouldn't trade oliver or fritsch, as primarily i don't think we'd get value for them (e.g. if the baggers really wanted fritsch, i would want harry mckay in a straight swap - they both offer the same scoreboard impact, but fritsch is a helluva lot less costly on the cap) while sparrow plays a role for us as that small pressure forward / mid, but he frustates me so much with his inconsistency in the role i don't think the likes of salem, petty will realise enough 'value' in a trade sense for us to part with them it's hard to see how we are going to get involved in the meat market that is the trade period this year unless one of fritsch, oliver, petracca demands a trade
  14. i unfortunately won't see much, if any, of the game live as i'll be at the community cup at vic park go the rockdogs, carn the dees
  15. they won tough last week vs gw$ they play a really tough, gritty style of football will be an attritional battle