Jump to content

whatwhat say what

Life Member
  • Posts

    14,647
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    6

Posts posted by whatwhat say what

  1. AFL Predictions:

    Brownlow Medal: Nathan Fyfe

    Coleman Medal: Buddy Franklin

    Rising Star: Brad Crouch

    Grand Finalists: Geelong V West Coast

    Premiers: Geelong

    Wooden Spoon: GWS

    Biggest AFL Story of the Year: It's already happened / is happening - the peptides / Essendon drug scandal

    The Biggest Improvers: Brisbane

    The Biggest Sliders: North Melbourne

    MFC Predictions:

    B&F: Nathan Jones

    Leading Goalkicker: Chris Dawes

    Best First Year Player: David Rodan

    Most Improved: Jack Watts

    Final Ladder Position: 15th

    Biggest MFC Story of the Year: Board turmoil

  2. I'm unsure as to why Howe is set to be stationed in the forward line this season.

    He showed real ability as a wingman in 2012.

    Sylvia is a classic [censored]-tease.

    I expect him to be very good for the Pies / Hawks / Swans / Tigers / Crows / Eagles / Whichever contender he goes to in 2014 and beyond.

    • Like 1
  3. Unsurprisingly, I'm in the no camp.

    We lack the depth and class required, and the history of development has been previously so poor that those who have been with the club over the journey can't possibly cut the mustard.

    Our skills have been woeful for years, and thus far show little signs of improvement under the current regime.

    One big difference though has been our fitness levels, which seem to have improved tenfold.

  4. His tackling was excellent last night, but the one thing he wasn't doing that he's not really done since his first year at the Dees is run to each contest with real intention to impact upon it - he just sort of mooches around the outside of the pack these days, rather than going and getting the ball.

    The contrast between him and Greene is extreme.

    Whether its instructions from GWS to be more of an outside player who knows, but when Greene is the only player who can get the ball for them in a pack they really need Scully to be the inside-outside player he promised to be.

    2013 looms as a big year for him. He needs to show a lot more.

  5. I've been espousing the completely socialist model of the pool of gate receipts being split evenly for at least a decade.

    I've spoken to people at the AFL about it, from 'rich' and 'poor' clubs about it, and the general feeling is it will never fly because of the likes of the Silks contingent will never support it.

    I still say it makes sense, and is by far and away the easiest way of evening things up - that way there's no need for a cap on external revenue sources (eg pokies, membership, merch sales etc) or football department spend.

    The latter will be the next thing that comes in I would imagine.

    It won't work, the wealthier clubs will continue to find a way around it.

    And the AFL changed their nomenclature to fixture from draw quite deliberately a few years back. It's forever destined to be uneven now as its geared towards tv revenue more than anything else.

    Great thread btw, really enjoyable reading.

    • Like 1
  6. Buddy was the biggest champ running around on gran final day 2012?

    A certain dual Brownlow medallist might have a case to argue about that...

    Swans have a host of players I'd consider superior to the Hawks, including one who used to be there.

    • Like 2
×
×
  • Create New...