Sir Why You Little

not when a player plays so poorly. his past form is irrelevant in that situation. But that is my opinion The example of David Warner is rather apt right now. His form prior to 2017 is completely irrelevant to his output in the ashes series just completed

what a player does season to season is one thing - Form Club Culture is a cumulative thing, it grows 55 years of no success defines the Club at this point. What Tomlinson did in 2017 is irrelevant, his form on Saturday was putrid. i hope he gets a chance to redeem himself

what he did 2 years ago is irrelevant now, but what he didn’t do on Saturday concerns me. GW$ almost played a man down

cheers. i am not judging him on 1 game. i am judging him on 1 Final. I hope he gets a 2nd one next Saturday

I haven’t seen a lot of Greater Waste of Space games to be honest, but Saturday nights game was a Cracker, except for Tomlinson, who was just awful. I hope he just had a bad game. we need real recruits, not the usual NQR opposition cast offs which has been the norm for so long. (Craig Turkey, The Cockatoo Collins twins, Tom Gillies, Shannon Byrnes as a few examples) Maybe he has checked out of the Franchaise already, which would be a bad sign. Finals maketh careers, attitude is what we need, the rest can be taught. i hope he plays in the Preliminary Final to redeem himself, i will be watching him closely

is he worth pick 2 Steve, compared to the (gun) 18 year old we can take? I only saw 3-4 Meth Coke games this year

You must be on new Medication dp. I would have the dosage adjusted first thing Monday morning

That is 24 Carrot GOLD!!!

What a game by Charlie Cameron after getting that injury in the first minute. Hyper extending the elbow. Wow that would be so painful. But he played a cracking game

Sadly the Lions choked 2 games they should have won GW$ are hideous

It is madness. Adrenaline flat out and off they come

That is an interesting question, i am not against an Umpire calling a free. But it is Not his job to Coach players on how to play the game.

It’s a physical game. Niggle has always been part of it

So pay a free. But don’t tell the players the rules, it is not right

Nothing wrong with testing out your opponent. Always been a part of the game

Umpires telling players how to play. THAT IS NOT YOUR JOB If a player goes over the limit then pay a free, Charlie Cameron has a bad arm, but it was his decision to come back on.

This reminds me of 2002 Semi against Adelaide massive Momentum Swings

Yep ? that’s 2019

What a cracking game. Best final for years Apart from us last year!!

Toby Greene is popular so far

Yes indeed or on the pavement between jobs... it is who you know.

Seems that way doesn’t it. Open the Floodgates....

"I've seen the (Hawkins) incident, what I will say is what I think in recent weeks in the AFL is moving away from suspensions. "I agree with the AFL's approach, you want the best players out there playing so I'd hope there's consistency in that." - Patrick Dangerfield 3AW Interview today what an absolute disgrace

Yep. The official just writes a full report on the events. Which certainly would not read well back at HQ