Sir Why You Little

So why do we never get the big key Forwards? Something we havent had Since Neita I understand what you are saying, but we regularly seem to get the worst deal out of a 2 way trade Why is that…Are we too nice??

Doesn’t mean a thing if the Gameplan isn’t working This is not personal, i am sure there is genuine love between Goody and his players But the results don’t lie, Goody continues to say “we will learn and get better”… Something continues to not be working….

I have mentioned JJ a number of times, once again, he is given free passage to go the Swans, making them stronger and we are left with Casey Regulars It’s like a 12 point turnaround

We have to rejuvenate the list, now Changes have to be made, or else we will be in 17th spot real fast Tasmania is not far away i understand your sentiment, i love Salo, his cafe was close to my home he is a Premiership Player, but he cannot play at top level anymore It is a brutal industry

He was asking what happened

You have missed the point completely the right decision was made between Gawn and Goodwin

Except that he agreed and left him out there….

Spot on. We Must Trade for Players who are ready to play Senior Football straight away We let Bedford go to GW$ and we still hope Laurie will make it, not only do we lose a good quick player, we make GW$ better and that doesn’t mention other blunders who cannot even get a Senior Game when players are injured. It is a complete F$&@ up

There is no doubt we have had a lot of bad luck, but so do most clubs. We just have not recovered well. We need to employ more recruiting staff around the country

You can hear the conversation during the 21 GF documentary

The advantages to Sydney have been incredible, going right back to the 90’s. The League get moist when Sydney are winning the advantage is far too much, but until other Clubs rise against it, it will continue imagine Tony Lockett walks in Followed immediately by Lance Franklin!!! He was supposed to go to GW$, but the League were just happy in reality that he was in NSW. Jeelong are the Sleepers with all their land deals. These should all be declared

Gawn told Goodwin to leave Jackson on in the middle during the 3rd, whilst Max was on the Bench

I don’t think Goodwin will go either, but this continuous push for “Contest & Defence” has gone too far. They are important elements, but the balance is out of alignment We need to get Run and Flair into the side. Look at the way GW$ carved us up wide on the ‘G and a Key Forward, maybe JVR or Jefferson will be going forward, but i still think we need to Trade in a Forward for 2025 Fullarton, Schache and McAdam gave us a big zero I think the whole Club needs a fresh start, last off season was a very bad time

We shall see about that. Lygon Street still exists You do know The MFC had Wayne Johnson all but stitched up don’t you…

Yes I know, so all the other points are interesting but not really relevant. The Club has done this to itself…

I have a fair idea of contracts and i also remember very well how Carlton used to do business. A very good friend of mine signed up about 5 players in WA back in the 70’s and 80’s when the Cash was flowing very freely from Lygon Street Laundromats. Remember the Carlton Motto ”We are Carlton, F$&@ the Rest…”

So it’s all smooth sailing then Saty As long as you are happy…. Our Trading has been atrocious since 2020 They are all Casey Standard Players, you cannot argue that. Other Clubs Top up regularly, but we can’t do it

You are talking Drafting, which has been great. Trading Ready made Senior Players has been utterly awful, they are all playing average games at Casey Other Clubs trade really well, we haven’t for 4 years, and it has killed the season Gambles don’t cut it, we need to target specific players, other Clubs do it

If our Trading in of players over the last 4 years hadn’t been so woefully bad, we would still be challenging, regardless of what you have said, which is all true

Either way heads have got to roll We cannot allow arrogance to be apart of decision making We haven’t traded in a Top Liner into the Club since Ed Langdon (Grundy aside) It’s just unacceptable

This is the Major problem. We have traded players in who are Casey regulars Trading has been appalling… Do outside players not want to come to The MFC, is it a problem?

We all see the trouble. Don’t need a Carlton Supporter with a glass of Red in his hand, to point it out. I would love to know how Carlton can keep all these Players on Big Contracts and be under the Salary Cap That would be a Fascinating read….

Still gotta do it

And let’s all hope that Carlton get Smashed Enough of your condescending Wine Glass

The “Star Fire 4…”