Everything posted by Bates Mate
-
Pert and Roffey - The Review Thread
She did acknowledge there was issues at the club. I wish Gerard asked her what they are. He was pretty soft with his questioning
-
Farewell Adam Tomlinson
Good luck to thommo. Remember when we recruited him he was going to play wing 🤦♂️
-
Caleb Daniel
Is he an upgrade or downgrade on bowey ?? No way we could have both in the team
-
Farewell Alex Neal-Bullen
On second thought I think this would mean effectively a anb for McAdam swap , yuk
-
Farewell Alex Neal-Bullen
They'll give us pick 25 , which is the pick we gave up for McAdam. . In that case you could say we got McAdam for free , which is about the right price based on this year's output
-
Trade Targets
I'm keen on Lukocious as well, great kick, can play both positions still young all ticks. Obviously Hardwick isn't a fan, he was great last year and played some great games this year
-
Christian Petracca
Weather it's all him or those around him or most likely both , the "strategy" has definitely hurt his "brand" . Just say he does force his way out to what seemingly is his wish of only the Pies or Blues who fit the big club in the window criteria . How good will it be for his brand ( let alone his mental health) if he does not perform at the level expected which is highly possible given his injuries. After selling the farm to get him the Pies or Blues fans are going to demand a Tracc at the top of his game relatively quickly and they are not the type of fans that will sit quietly and wait for him to perform. The groans of 60K Collingwood supporters at the G isn't a happy place .
-
How Many Weeks For Kozzy?
Same, only reason I go to games anymore is the fact I meet up with my parents and sister and take my kids so it's a family thing. I've stopped caring as much as I used to and only frequent this forum and some demon podcasts.the while AFL machine makes me angry across so many levels
-
Delistings 2024
What a disappointing career for schace given his draft position and hype. He'll dominate some suburban league next year. Good luck to him
-
Christian Petracca
His brand is already one of if not the biggest in the AFL. I don't get this part of it
-
My 3 word player analysis V Collingwood
No but I saw them. Never met a supporter who just watches for mistakes
-
My 3 word player analysis V Collingwood
Watched him closely 20 kicks 10 where from kick ins . That he kicked high to a pack everytime. 7 rebounds from defensive 50 for 5 turnovers . I wouldn't expect any one to watch that Trainwreck again but if you did you'd see he was not good
-
My 3 word player analysis V Collingwood
I thought Salem was awful. Took too long to kick the ball when he had it , including on kick ins. Turned it over multiple times. Choose the wrong option majority of the time.
-
POSTGAME: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
I hate the filth, but they do have a game plan and system that all the players know and execute well, because they are skilled and smart footy players. Yes they won't be in finals but they'll own us for years to come and be back up the ladder next year. Us not so sure . The chocco Williams kicking academy is worse than Trump University
-
Laurie Extends for 2 More Years
But that preseason though, trained the house down!!
-
Luke Parker open to move
100% nailed it my thoughts exactly
-
Farewell Alex Neal-Bullen
Yes with limited grey matter
-
Farewell Alex Neal-Bullen
Adelaide have the ability to rise up the ladder next year so their future second may be not worth much more or even worse
-
Greg Stafford departs Melbourne
Who do we blame if our forward line sucks next year??!!
-
NON-MFC: Round 23
Game over Essendon have done it again, first half season specialists. Almost fell sorry for their supporters , almost
-
NON-MFC: Round 23
Glorious, seeing Essendon [censored] the bed and miss finals is somewhat softening the blow of our season. Carlton and Collingwood miss out and I'm satisfied
-
Christian Petracca
That maggot Craig McCrae ,"jokingly" saying trac would look great in black and white and they'd love to have him. Can even have his car park. In the US this would be considered tampering and cop a massive fine . But it's Collingwood and flea just a bit of banter. Seriously planting a seed like this shouldn't be allowed
-
Dan Houston
So Houston only became aware of all these "issues" after a Tom Morris report and the subsequent SEN , AFL.com, hS page page and airtime fillers in the last 3 days.... Please
-
Best Presser Ever!!
I applaud his level of bravery to get out on the field , but seems really dumb for the club to allow him to play while so banged up. I was one who got stuck into Clarry at times this year due to what he has produced on field which has been way below his standard and barely AFL standard recently. He should never have been playing with such injuries I thought we learned our lesson in 2022 by selecting the effectively the same 22 every week when we have able replacements playing good footy at Casey and not manage players after the 10-0 start ,we saw what happened in finals.
-
Season 2024 Over for Clayton Oliver
Good, will be a net positive for the final 2 rounds. He's been between serviceable and liability for much of the season and his last 3 weeks diabolical. Amw back in ,Judd more midfield please. We need to make clarry earn his spot through performance next year