The rising star award is a joke.
First look at the judges:
Gillon McLachlan
Mark Evans
Danny Frawley
Warren Tredrea
Glen Jakovich
Cameron Ling
Luke Darcy
Matthew Richardson
Kevin Bartlett
Kevin Sheehan
Second, how on earth did they vote Lewis Taylor over Marcus Bontempeli?
Third, a lot of past winners careers have only been serviceable, Chris Scott (I know he won premierships, but a rising star and best player of his crop?), Michael Wilson, Justin Koschitzke, Rhys Plamer, Paul Halesby & Jared Rivers.
Fourth, there are a lot of misses over the years. Not many Brownlow medalists or Coleman medalists in the honour roll; only three have won a Brownlow so far (Buckley, Goodes, and Cousins)
Fifth, the eligibility criteria is all over the shop. Some guys have been nominated twice (Jordan Gysberts and Sam Blease stand up please). Although the list of dual nominees looks almost as good as the winners list.
So in my opinion, it will be OK if Jesse does not win the award.