Half forward flank

All we can do is win, pretty obvious, but if we fall short Goody has to take off next year where we left off. Be open to Viney not being in the centre square at the start of each game. Harmes is not a half back, Brayshaw is not a wingman, Brown fills Watts role. Keep a settled backline. Settle jackson into the side. Encourage Jordan, Sparrow.

I would consider no change, even allowing for some poor individual performances, AVB maybe, but you cannot bring in Harmes, no form line. ANB, maybe, but he kicked an early goal, Jetta maybe, but he is heart and soul. I might just roll the winning dice.

The first thing I would do with Jack if he stays would try and help him decide when to leave the ball for others, both Dees players and the opposition. He often miraculously and with courage gets balls he is not really expected to. He could instead, wait, sweat on the opposition player, tackle and earn a free kick instead of getting the ball in an impossible position to dispose of freely.

Yes, I have always thought we can get carried away with midfielders for just getting touches. Especially rucking to Max. I love to see it mixed up.

Great win, Great coaching from the opening with Trac forward. Young blokes showed some dash and dare. Likely shows how unbalanced we were playing all of Trac, Oliver, Viney, Harmes, Brayshaw and Jones. Individually good but to much of a likeness.

Yes, Kossie got us going.

Well played, good coaching, great jumper.

Mummy is threatening to take this game from us. Who is gonna stand up against him.

Rubbish and you know it.

Well, you said we trained up a key back. Who was he? Even who were they if you cant as is obvious name the one who replaced Frawley.

Who was the key back we trained up.

D minus fro comprehension Heart.

Of course you get the best people in the key roles with the exception being the Pres must have impecable credentils. were Goodwin Mahoney Pert all the best available?

Hardly to blame for the rear guard on here not understanding I am talking about people who not only played for the Dees but never supported them. I am talking about haveing no passinate Melb people on board. Or are you saying women are not allowed to have a role in Club. By inference you are if they must have played. × “I don’t necessarily blame Simon Goodwin, it’s a collective. If Josh Mahoney has got this wrong, why doesn’t the feedback go up the chain a little bit? Is it Josh Mahoney (General Manager of Football), is it Gary Pert (CEO), how are they going with their roles? “I think this is a full club problem, not just the senior coach.”

Interested to hear other but I think if you asked supporters to name half a dozen values you would like us to stand for I doubt ruthless would come up. Way down from professional, reliable, competitive ,enterrtaining............

Not talking about playing for the Club you hold an important position at. Talking about supporting that Club.

I expected that, and you fell in.

The fact is the Tigers have three passionate Tiger people in the key roles. Gale, Peggy and Emmet Dunne. If you think those three would have brought the same time commitment and passion to a Club they never supported thats up to you.

So you say.

You would back whoever is in charge.

name a Premiership side that has not has one of their own inone of the four key post.

Again no comparison Barlett played for West Coast Peggy had no allegieance before coming to Melb. Note you are no including Brendan Gale with your Cherry picking I am making the point not one of the four key posts is occupied by a true Dee

I am talking about outsider in the four key posts.

All fine, but we have not brought in the best people. We are seven years into what PJ stated and started. Still no stable coaching, List full of holes, Poor team performances, No home base. Beyond that what other GF winning Club has not one true supporter/player in the four key posts.

Not a compaison . We have no true Dees in the four key posts. Tigers had Peggy and Gale as passionate players/supporters.