Colm

Would love if we got him. He’s probably ahead for the riding start at the minute. Had a great start to his AFL career. Might make sense too. Bolton and Kossie both play a similar role, splitting their time between forward and the middle with licence to roam. Need role players around those types of players not sure Reid is a role player.

Ok folks I think we have all made our points. Can we get back on topic about how good the lad is. Agree with others that his pace seems fine to me. For me he’s a great wing man to have on the opposite wing to Langers. A great target when we are coming out of defence with his height and contested marking and great player to link up with forwards with his kicking ability. Also seems to have great positional awareness and ability to find the ball.

People seem to be annoyed we took our foot of the gas in the last quarter and I get that, but for me the much bigger concern is we only put our foot on the gas in the third. Where was the intensity in the first half ? We were a different side once we decide to have a crack, lift our pressure and put a few tackles in. Prime time slot, amazing pre game ceremony over 70k fans. Apart from KB our biggest game of the year and we only went to proper levels of intensity for one quarter. Are we not fit enough? Or just not interested enough?

Maybe in a small way. It’s mooted that they will get access to Tasmanian players in 2027 before they have a proper selection of picks in 2028. However that’s if everything goes according to plan and they have will have their stadium ready in time ( I think 2030) which is starting to look unlikely.

Bugger I was really hoping Warner would go to Freo , would have made a play for Kossie much more difficult. They also now know what money they can offer Kossie.

I’m guessing our future first pick will be on the trade table again this year so.

I think he’s probably got a fair whack considering it was his first offence. I assume he was told he’s somebody was fighting with his brother and he’s rung out and completely over reacted. Think the judge did well enforcing the curfew as it affects him for the next 3 months. The fact that he has a public profile means much more attention and shame brought to him and his family. If similar footage of Steven May came out would people be as quick to be calling for him to be jailed?! My problem is with Richmond and the AFL. They both should have been much harder on him. 4 game ban- Kossie got 3 for a bump that was a fraction late and a fraction high. Doesn’t seem to add up, the two things aren’t in the same league and doesn’t set a good example for kids. I guess players getting concussion might cost them money. Kids having their lives ruined by a coward punch not so much.

I agree with others that we should put a big front ended offer in front of him. Until Freo know if they will land Chad Warner or not they may not be in a position to make Kossie as big an offer. He’s pure class when he’s up and about, be gutted to lose him.

Interesting stat. Most of the current top ranked players are about the same age as Trac and Clarry would have been when we won the flag. I guess the demands of the modern game catches up on players quicker these days. On the plus side we don’t have to wait as long to have the likes of Kolt, Windsor, XL, Langford and JVR hitting their peak.

100% agree. Forget about Butters, LDU and Allen types for now. We’re no chance. We need to be looking at players that struggle to get a game elsewhere. Like Bedford and JJ when they left is. Hawks failed to bring in the majority of players they targeted for years instead took whoever they could get and developed them. Get that part right and then you can target quality free agents.

I was thinking this as well. We looked a level below the Cats all night. So many tackles didn’t stick, they seem to be far more agile than us and be able to side step tackles at will. Our last quarters have been poor in every game. Geelong looked fitter, stronger and faster.

Sounds to me like Tom Morris has been reading Demonland again.

No I don’t think we will be in the running. But 3 of those club are big Victorian clubs that must have the cap space and capital to make it happen. Worth noting if we are willing to part with Trac. I had been wondering about the Bombers as a destination for him should he want out again this year.

I’m not completely on the “Goody must go” bandwagon just yet but I’m having a good look to see if there room for one more there. I like Goody and will always be grateful for the flag and will always have happy memories of him. What I will say is that I’m not in favour of him seeing the season out if he’s not going to be here at the start of next season. If we are going to make the call I would rather we do it around the bye. I know it will probably be harder to recruit a new coach mid season as most will be involved with other clubs but I think it would be better than waiting until the end of season. It would give us the jump on other clubs who will be looking for coaches, it would allow the new coach to have a proper look at the cattle he has to work with and how the club runs. Would also allow him to have input into player comings and goings and who might be best suited to the game plan he will implement. At this stage I would be saying to Goody you have until round 10 to turn it around. He deserves the fans and clubs respect but at some stage we will have to make a call if things don’t improve.

I wouldn’t get rid of both and would probably rather Trac went before Clarry. It’s not a matter of them getting back to 100% or not. It’s a matter of us needing capital to rebuild. We have to move quickly and try to rebuild before Tasmania comes in.