adonski

We'd have to give up a future first for a B grader. Not sure.

I was expecting about 2 comments. Defs overs.

Cogs dropped

Effort only goes so far. Retaining Jack backs the effort philosophy, in retaining a player who constantly gives their all. Letting him go backs the talent...allows Brayshaw to play a bigger role & getting a highly rated player in through the draft who may have a higher ceiling than Jack. It's an interesting one.

Surely if Jack goes, we then go hard for Williams with the cap room, then take the pick to the draft for the best outside player/small forward available. The old 2 for 1...!

We'll bring Gaff across then they'll make it 16v16 with the wing position removed.

Definitely not what I imagined Gunston looked like but there are some odd hair do's these days so anythings possible

Straight swap for Tomlinson? But in all seriousness, what does that mean for Tomlinson? He's not a winger, I think the clubs aware of that, too.

Should get a Buddhist monk in the guts then

All of the above can be true but Gus is still more talented...!

Never heard of him

Was Viney in a port jersey

What % chance you giving that he goes

I rate Brayshaw higher but at the same time dunno if he'll ever get back to 2018 levels on consistency, even without Jack - worth the risk tho, imo!

No way they haven't, but perhaps they've shaved some dollerydoo's off?

Viney to join Gus at Freo?

I would suspect he’s read it on BigFooty

Not sure what people see in Sparrow

Let Viney walk and trade Brayshaw to justify recruiting more inside mids is the master plan

What compo pick would we get

Viney, Wines, Rockliff, SPP? They’ve got so many similar players, where have you heard this

Prediction: we trade our future first for two picks in the 20s

I reckon we're similar to Richmond when they kept finishing 9th. Have a few obvious guns, but the bottom 6-8 that play every week are absolute squids. I think it's more about addressing the bottom handful of players (replacing C graders with B graders) than it is landing a big fish like Williams, etc.

Salem, Lever both had decent years Harmes and to a lesser extent Brayshaw played out of position T Mac is anyones guess