waynewussell

Weideman for Tomlinson (McDonald to continue down back) Chandler if Fritsch gets weeks Harmes if Baker is dropped

The negativity around Melksham is bordering on War of The Worlds mass hysteria. If you took the time to watch the second half replay you might notice that Melksham played a key link-up role in our recovery... Nah! you wouldn't notice!

So, you take the name of one of our all-time greats then come on here and call a player a "spud"; classy act you've got going there in your marathon contribution of 143 posts!

The 1999 quartette played 763 games between them... going to be very difficult to surpass! The 1986 trio played 522

Yes, SPC... that was a very good year. In 1986 we drafted Steven Febey, Matthew Febey, Andy Lovell & Darren Jarman!!! Then added Andrew Obst, Steven Tingay and Jay Viney in 1987 Another fair year was 1997 with Travis Johnston, Nathan Brown and Guy Rigoni Should we even mention 2009 with Scully Trengove & Max Gawn?

6 - Oliver 5 - Salem 4 - Petracca 3 - Kossie 2 - ANB 1 - Langdon

When opinion is being tossed around I like to provide perspective. You are entitled to read the facts as you want. From my POV, I'm not surprised by the crowd numbers, nor do I see them as evidence that the sky is falling. Please note that this is an automatically generated post, replies will not be answered.

Yesterday’s attendance of 21365 was the 4th highest out of a total of 15 occasions that Melbourne have met Freo at the MCG (3rd highest on a Sat aft). Here is the complete list. Year Result Attendance Day / Time 1996 W 15494 Fr (n) 1997 W 15036 Sat (aft) 1998 W 20365 Sat (aft) 1999 L 19178 Fr (n) 2003 L 17009 Sat (aft) 2005 L 21963 Sun (aft) 2006 W 23368 Sat (aft) 2007 L 16654 Sun (aft) 2008 W 19423 Sun (aft) 2009 W 13004 Sun (aft) 2011 W 19092 Sun (aft) 2013 L 13768 Sun (aft) 2017 L 27829 Sat (aft) 2019 W 20211 Sat (aft) 2021 W 21365 Sat (aft)

I haven't participated in this thread because I don't care what Mark Maclure thinks!

I think we have to be honest, we did not look like a top 8 team... and I have been watching the other pre-season games. Freemantle looked a lot better than us. I see a real struggle until we get Brown, Viney and the likes of Hibberd, Melksham & Weiderman back

Didn't help their cause... AVB, Harmes, Hunt, Spargo & Baker.

I think the selection, or non selection was flawed. Brayshaw & Oliver should have played. Our selection just exposed too many young blokes at once, which condemns them to a hiding.

Disappointed in the young guys that were given the opportunity, Jordan, Sparrow & Bedford. I thought Bowey showed more intent and skill in his cameo than any of them. Umpiring was pro Bulldog, blind eye to Gawn & May.

Brilliant recruiting, hampered by knee injury, about to become one of the best defenders in AFL.

Thanks Picket, I like your work... especially the update on Tom Mac!

Jake had an ordinary year in 2020, no doubt about it! I fall into the group that suspects Hub-life didn't bring the best out of him (growing family etc) rather than the group that believes all talent that this bloke displayed over a significant period suddenly vanished; evaporated - consigning him to the scrapheap! Short-sighted and short memories there, I believe.

Just to give some perspective on goal assists... Melksham - 65 from 71 games Brad Green - 85 from 254 Cam Bruce - 71 from 224 Adam Yze - 40 from 271

Q: Why is Melksham valued? A: 8th highest goal assists at MFC since 1965 Top 20 marks inside 50 for MFC since 1965 4th highest goal kicker on current list This from 71 games in R&B to date.

"I just have the feeling they will get to a flag before us. What you see as negative I see as realism." We are talking about Carlton, right? The Carlton with this recent record... 2020 11th 2019 16th 2018 18th 2017 16th 2016 14th 2015 18th 2014 13th 2013 8th (was that the Essendrug year?) Can someone please point out how that record represents development?

The team that would rather die than amalgamate? Don't make me laugh, Jeff! The Tassie Govt are seriously contemplating pulling out on support of both Nth & Dawks deals with AFL. They have made it very clear, they want their own team. Tassie folk are prepared to turn their backs on AFL if they don't get a get date for entry to the elite comp. AFL involvement at the grass roots level has already taken a worrying dive, with junior numbers in BB and Soccer increasing rapidly... Asleep at the wheel, Gill... irrelevant, Jeff!

Jeff Farmer, who was the first indigenous AFL player to kick 400 goals, was drafted in an exchange for Phil Gilbert! Maybe draft position is only a moderate predictor!

Sorry, NeveroddoreveN... I tried to post Axis of Bob's excellent analysis post from days gone by, not sure I succeeded... however, highly recommended when discussing Viney's worth.

My analysis figures are directly from AFL rating points which are established from a formula that covers a wide range of indicators. In a counter argument to yours, these ratings include goals (which advantages forwards over most mid-fielders). Obviously, this approach enables a data based comparison across player positions.

In the past 3 meetings Dixon averages 1 goal against the Demons, Hawkins averages 1 goal and Lynch averages just over 2... Hardly a respectable outcome against VFL Backmen... I would have to say on that showing that all three are nearing the end!