dino rover

Who gets more taps king or pedo / watts? Who does more defence offence when rucking?

Is it time to play Mitch King? Yes he isnt ready but arent we diminishing other players and positions covering the ruck role? Would it hasten or slow Kings development? Would it stabilise our back six if tmac just played back? Could watts offer more if not a ruck reserve? Pedersen fwd offering a relief ruck role?

The same practise that has not transformed his field kicking? I think what we have done is in covering ruck we have weakened other positions. Tmac is a defender.

He cant kick goals

Disagree Our supposed leaders in vince lewis and jones were poor The young in hunt frost showed leadership

I liked hunt and hannan forward with jeffy they provide max pressure to the defence I want kent and stretch in for the same reason but have hunt and stretch higher / wings I drop jkh and vince

Jones q1 butcher

Listening to goody post match I think they will and perhaps must try something radical with 2 traditional rucks out Pedo doesnt have the tank for a long ruck gig Tmac would have the tank and while he may lose the tap - after the tap and between ruck contests he might offer more - watts does

Neal bullen's kick off the ground oob on full killed us

Maybe Kent was dropped for lack tackles. If so Smith had 11 vs Williamstown. Jkh may also be seen as bringing more fwd defensive pressure as well as offensive potency Watts in the ruck works on two levels it rests spencer but it also intensifies jack - it might be a stretch but it seems to have given him more physical presence - evidenced by more contested marking

Does he have any overdue library books?

I want randomized control trial evidence, peer review, ethical approval and a comfy chair

Getting dropped?

Thx

What was the ANB clanger count? At the time in the stands I thought he turned it over a lot. Was that right?

There is no talk here about the opposition We weren't playing f@ckin witches hats Sandy fyfe neal hill and McCarthy (?) There is some class there and we didnt couldnt match it For all our supposed midfield strength we only fought to at best a draw -our defense was better for frost but vince and melksham are mostly ballast Trac is quality but not quantity and some butchery Agree on weed a boy on a mans mission

If a defender then you need to break lines by foot or pace and have defensive awareness He doesnt break lines no more I cant see him in the middle and what does he bring fwd?

Like young players dlanders panic at moments of adversity A balanced view is that he is one player I dont know what his roles have been what his opponents have done or what his coaches view is I doubt captaincy is some cross he carries Im as gutted as the rest of you just struggling to maintain some perspective

Causation vs correlation? What evidence?

Credit to freo who have been underestimated Kent spencer frost bugg and watts good Anb too many turnovers

Mario milano?

Smoking also causes sanctimonious sermons

Thanks for your good wishes Mine got better but whether it was the prp or general recovery who could say Its off topic but some treatments are ahead of the curve unsupported by evidence base (randomized controlled trials and peer review) is that a problem - maybe because players get experimented on. Has gawn got hamstring tendonopathy? Surgery only one path in our experience

Quick call the fun police

Dr phillip bloom cfc doctor - treated me for hamstring tendenopathy using platelet rich plasma injections a somewhat unproven treatment that bloom favours and administers Bloom is a sports physician (more qualified) than a gp Dr phil baressi was the previous cfc doctor and he resigned in the wake of the essendrug scandal because the pressure was on club doctors to bend rules I worked at the college of surgeons and medicos are just as flawed as other mortals but in the case of concussion they would should be very careful