dazzledavey36

Brayshaw needs to be dropped plain and simple. It's either McDonald comes in or they go like for like and bring in Tomlinson who I also thought was stiff initially to be dropped. Plus he plays the wing role a lot more better then Gus.

Bevo was right all along when Clarko made those comments..

I honestly thought Tomlinson was stiff initially to be dropped. I'd be bringing him in this week for Gus who was worst on ground.

This year has brought on a new hatred for AFL as a sport with all the rule changing etc. After that Kozzie Pickett tackle that was deemed dangerous, I now just hate the game even more with a passion. If Melbourne decided to ever shut up shop for good ( not that it ever will) then I would easily be satisfied knowing i would never have to watch this sport again. Only thing keeping me going is watching my beloved Dees. The umpiring and rule changing is killing all enjoyment out of the game and its dying a slow death. Pity Gill cannot see that...

I'm a fan of fitting in all three of Weideman, Jackson and McDonald into our forward line.

He's showing good signs for a KPF. I feel like with each game time, he will just get better. I've always been in the camp that we could always fit in Weideman, McDonald and Jackson in the one side. Bringing in McDonald means Jackson takes the 3rd tall defender and doesn't shoulder burden of taking a big body. For a guy that's near 200cm, he sure is agile!

This. He'll only get better with each game and experience.

Unfortunately I think that loss has cost us this year. We still need at least 6-7 wins and yet i just cannot see that happening. This has 2017 written all over again.

Yes Brayshaw was Worst on ground. Harmes was far behind him though. Trying to turn Harmes into a defender has unfortunately halted his development to a degree this year.

Not sure if you were watching the game tonight chell, but Harmes played a lot of game time in the middle, where as Gus played the whole game on the wing. Harmes was not far behind Brayshaw in being the worst player on the night. Continues to just give away stupid free kicks which cost momentum or give up a goal to the opposition. The blokes thinks he's Dustin Martin half the time and infuriats me that he has the gonads to always argue back with the umpire when he gets pinged holding the ball all the time.

Excuses. He was by far our worst player tonight.

Agree 100%

That would be my out. Bring in Tomlinson and perhaps Rivers.

Maybe ask why Fritta lead tight right on the boundary..

If Harmes isn't holding on to a jumpers and giving away a free, he's then trying to break tackles and gets pinged for it. Dead set so predictable.

Unfortunately I just see him going down the same path as Tyson. I feel he's hit his ceiling.

He had two mares. Other than that he was solid. He's making Lever and May become better players. That's enough to have him in the side.

Trade. See ya.

its curtains already.

I am officially off Brayshaw. Needs to be dropped and traded at years end. Slow, fumbles and no intensity at all. An absolute training cone out there.

Just hand the ball over. You're taught this right from auskick. Have no idea why he needed to [censored] around with it when he was deep in the pocket. That then would have resulted in a kick down the line to a 50/50 contest for Brisbane. Hope he gets his backside kicked hard.

See ya Jetta. Its time you retire gracefully. So many missed opportunities. Harley, Pickett, Harmes, Weideman. The umpiring was dead set the worse ive seen it this year, and its been an absolute debacle.

Well done Fritta you [censored] spanner

Bayley Frietch you are dead set [censored] idiot

Oscar back to doing dumb [censored] like he use too. His reaction time is [censored] putrid