dazzledavey36

Geelong are well known for taking unders and Hawthorn in their glory days as well took unders to keep all their stars. We on the other hand just give out these long term contracts on ridiculous money like its hot cakes.

Up there with one of the biggest list blunders we've made. It really didn't need to happen.

Ring ring... "Hello this is horse speaking?"

I didn't watch a minute of the game as I was playing footy today. What the actual [censored] happened??

Don't change Melbourne selection committee..

Mentha train?

I think Salem has been fine, but geez we're scraping at the bottom of the barrel if we're using this as a metric to judge how good he's been.. Good point.

I like the ins. Ringing back aome quality experience which we desperately need. Baffled that Sharp gets another go.

There was certainly contradiction from Goodwin last night and another good lesson why you take everything he says now with a grain of salt. We heard him and Pert say in a SEN interview in October 2023 that we have the best culture in 40 years, but yet last night he admitted that we were dealing with internal player issues around that time. In a press conference last year after the GWS defeat towards the back end of the year there was a question posed to Goodwin regarding Oliver trade speculation. He openly said this: "He's a Melbourne person through and through. He's not going anywhere. "He's a proud Melbourne person, we love him, we love the work that he's done. "We'll get his footy right, and he's going to be here for a long, long time playing some great footy." Then last night he admitted there was discussions around Oliver in whether he would be best suited elsewhere and other options be assessed but unfortunately that got out to the press before it actually got to Oliver first. I'm not sure it was going to eventuate but clearly the club had circled his name around trade discussions.

That is true.

I feel like the Paul Roos and Neale Daniher days were probably the most stable we had been from an off field perspective, certainly in my time supporting the dees. There were a lot of board issues during the Daniher years but the Rev did an incredible job in keeping the players united and not caught up in all the jargon. The only behaviour issue I can think of was David Neitz getting a bouncer in a headlock at Crown Casino? Roosy was highly respected within media circles and obviously his reputation probably played a big part in that. Fair to say he also kept the players in line with his standards around culture and behaviours.

Watched it last night. Most of you have covered it off fairly well. One thing that stood out to me and a good lesson to be learnt for the usual suspects on here that continue to sprout how good our environment and culture is on and off field. Matter of fact is, it hasn't been.. Goody actually confessed that there were a lot of internal issues going on inside the club with players and staff from about late 2022 to 2023, which then spilled into last year. Its why as he said, "Petracca didn't feel loved" His last answer to the question was awkward only because i do take into account it was filmed weeks prior to round one. Hamish asked, "what do we expect from Melbourne of 2025?" And Goody said something along the lines of 'Players being happy out on the MCG, smiling and loving what they're doing'. There was no reference whatsoever to change in game plan or adjusting our ball movement etc etc. My immediate thought was obviously seeing the complete opposite last Sunday with players looking completely bereft of confidence and dejected. I'm actually annoyed with the timing of this being shown last night instead of a few weeks backs. You seriously couldn't pick a worse time.

Yes but there is no way he gets to us.

That's pretty damning to read.

Give me this kind of footy analysis everyday of the week.

Without hesitation.

You do realise there is a suppress order in play regarding this matter right? So yeah, it's not allowed to be mentioned amongst media and journalism. Collingwood and Essendon have had their fair share of off field matters over the years. I said this the other day, Collingwoods dates back to the rat pack days and as recent as the DeGoey and Lumumba situation.. what more do you want? I can keep reeling off a list if you'd like? This whole poor me mentality that we are the only club copping it in the media is simply cringe and a case of having your red and blue lenses on and nothing else and im not simply directing this at you only even though you're the OP.

No they don't.

Taking stab here but I think this interview may have been filmed weeks ago?

Every media journo watching tonight.

I hope so. You can probably add Laurie to that list of delisted/trade. Do the club give Campbell another year or does he retire? There is also question marks on McAdam as well and then the obvious one is Kozzie Pickett..