WERRIDEE

It's going to be the Lewis\Vince scenario both can't both be in the same team. Lewis out for mine.

Went to the game. Started off in a blaze of glory kicking the first 4 and then it was all Box Hill. Really disappointed in the way the Dees played I thought Smith was the only one to hold his head high. Hutchins is a terrible captain can only play full back he's a terrible forward. Got smashed in the ruck it almost cost us the game last week and it cost us this week. Don't know what Lefau gives the side would prefer King he could not have done any worse than the other ruckman. Disappointed with Keilty made too many mistakes for my liking. Wagner and Lockhart didn't do their chances any good with getting picked up in the draft not their best days. Wagner is a plodder. Garlett was Garlett flashy but really didn't do a lot. Kennedy Harris is not up to AFL level nor is Bugg. Vince retired at the right time. Fritsch was classy rarely wastes the ball. Should be playing AFL. Petty showed some promise with a few great marks. Pedo was Pedo tried hard but didn't have a great game. 2 Grand Final losses in 3 years it's hard to swallow.

Best 22 I love it. B: Lever, Frost, Jetta HB: Salem, O.McDonald, Hibberd C : Fritsch, Oliver, Brayshaw HF: Petracca, Hogan, Neal-Bullen F: Melksham, T.McDonald, Weideman FOLL: Gawn, Viney, Harmes IC: Jones, Hannan, Vandenberg, Preuss Casey B: J.Smith, Keilty, Lewis HB: Hunt, Petty, Wagner C : Kennedy Harris, Stretch, Baker HF: Kent, T.Smith, Spargo F: Garlett, Draft Pick, Walker FOLL: Bradtke, Maynard, Draft Pick IC: Johnstone, McKenna, Draft Pick, Draft Pick Let Lewis rot in the 2's and Tyson must be traded.

Really disappointed in Clarry's game in the first half didn't have a tag and I thought he would have a blinder but was no where to be seen.

Really proud with the club this season the future looks bright but the game against West Coast can't be swept under the rug. Usual Melbourne when the pressure hits we go to water. Couldn't hit the side of a barn with hand or foot only Brayshaw tried. Lewis disgusting Jones wasn't much better our leadership was poor. Tyson is finished should have been dropped for Smith and Spargo has to learn how to kick if he's going to make it. We must learn from this and make sure we go on to bigger and better things. Fully fit Hogan and Lever will help this.

The big dance is here and I'm expecting a comfortable 20 point win to the dees . Good to see McKenna back Fritsch is a huge in. Vince to get BOG and replace Smith for the Grand Final when we hopefully make it. IC: Collis, Lefau, Stockdale and White

Changed my mind good move from the club, Tyson very lucky but Smith to Vardy is a good move.

Stupid move to drop Fritsch if it's true. It's going to be a tight game but the dees will come through and win by 6 points. Clarry BOG.

GO YOU GOOD THING CASEY. BERNIE'S A GUN HOW GOOD WAS SMITH'S INTERCEPT? I'M GOING ON SUNDAY BRING THE PREMIERSHIP HOME DEES

KING THE CLOWN

WHAT A WIN VINEY BULIT FOR SPTEMBER GAWN A COLOSES. C'MON DEES YOU CAN DO IT ONE MORE WIN AND WE ARE IN A GRANNY.

NO CHANGE WE ARE ON FIRE!

6 Viney 5 Gawn 4 T.McDonald 3 Petracca 2 Jetta 1 Oliver

No changes is big. We are an inform side playing with plenty of confidence while the Hawks had a shattering loss and have lost Stratton and O'Meara if we can't beat them now we will never beat them. I predict that we will win by 24 points.

Big prelim coming up. I'm expecting the Dees to get up by 18 points. Unfortunately McKenna's out just when he was starting to find some form. JKH and especially Vince are big ins. IC: Lefau, Munro, Scott, White, T.Freeman

Pedersen finished with 11 and Bugg 10.

The dirtiest player in the AFL. I hate him but he is a good player. It should be outlawed what he's been doing.

Should of recorded it.

Gun I can't believe people thought he had a bad game and wanted him delisted when he wasn't on the park. As someone said a wild card.

What would Freo give up then? Forget Langdon and they would have to give up that much to get him.

We have the Weid and their was some worrying signs from Hogan late in the year.

Trade Hogan for Neale, Langdon and pick 6 (Max King) and swap 2nd round picks to get O'Halloran. I think that is a good deal. Hogan is no longer needed and is on huge money I think we should make the move now.

NO CHANGE

We are playing some great football ATM hopefully we can keep it up for another 3 weeks. We have really found a gun in Weid, maybe Hogan for pick 6 and Neale isn't so crazy overall. GO THE MIGHTY DEES!

6 Weideman 5 Harmes 4 Lewis 3 Salem 2 Oliver 1 Viney