Ryan Murphy

[occo 2]

Just wandering if people still want this kid? Hasnt been much talk about him in last few days. Personally i would love to get this guy and would be happy to use pick 28 on him. This sorts out a hole for Neitz when he retires and the ruck situation is better, but be better if we got Moran.

Use pick 4 - Palmer (midfield)

Use pick 14 (if TJ goes) - Rance (FB)

Use pick 28 - Murphy

I personally think thats ok in a year where after pick 25 looks ordinary

[Redleg 40,827]

Just wandering if people still want this kid? Hasnt been much talk about him in last few days. Personally i would love to get this guy and would be happy to use pick 28 on him. This sorts out a hole for Neitz when he retires and the ruck situation is better, but be better if we got Moran.

Use pick 4 - Palmer (midfield)

Use pick 14 (if TJ goes) - Rance (FB)

Use pick 28 - Murphy

I personally think thats ok in a year where after pick 25 looks ordinary

How did we get pick 28?

Agree though I would have a go at Murphy and Moran. The pick we get for CJ could be used to get Moran and Murphy for our pick 21 or what we get for Miller if he goes.

[occo 2]

How did we get pick 28?

Agree though I would have a go at Murphy and Moran. The pick we get for CJ could be used to get Moran and Murphy for our pick 21 or what we get for Miller if he goes.

Sorry pick 21 i meant.

Although i would be sad to lose pick 21, there arnt many forwards which have already shown a lot of development. Its less risky than drafting a kid who has not played at AFL level yet. This would give us pick 4, 14 (if TJ leaves), 53 and 69 yes?.

4 - Palmer

14 - Rance

21 - Moran

[davey_magik 1]

These players would have to agree to nominate and realise they could be picked up earlier, and they would also have to accept normal draftee wages (60,000 a year I think on a two year deal).

[Gorgoroth 12,921]

murphy would be good but is he worth 21? i would not give any higher for him.

[occo 2]

murphy would be good but is he worth 21? i would not give any higher for him.

yeah you are possibly correct. Pick 21 is very high and could be valuable. I cant see any more trades happening to melbourne now after Tj which is fine by me