Remember that young Irish guy,(?Nick) Murphy we tried on our supp. list about 5or6 years ago(we sent him to St Kevins, but he didn't make AFL). I spoke to him at a club function, and asked if he'd played on the prospective boom no.1 draft pick at Caulfield Grammar(Judd) while representing StKevins. He said, yeah, the dirty b..... trod on my guts and deliberately twisted his foot around,with all his weight on it,during a scrimmage. I remember thinking,"perhaps we don't want him at Melbourne!" (Still had hopes at the time, and knew he supported the Demons).

This fits in with his recent blatant gouge, when he couldn't possibly have argued he was acting for his own safety.He cotradicted the panel's statement that only his hand was on Brown's face. He said himself it was hand AND fingers(when you think about it, it would have to be.)

As for the WCE official comparing his image to Hird's..what rubbish! AND,where were the fines for public statements(by Judd, Malthouse and other WCE officials) trying to influence the tribunal?

I still wish he played for us, despite his mean streak!!!

He is a champion.

You can't be an AFL champion if you're soft.

No mean streak = no stardom.

But he is not a dirty player, and man what I wouldn't give to see him being no so squeaky clean at Melbourne!!!

He said, yeah, the dirty b..... trod on my guts and deliberately twisted his foot around,with all his weight on it,during a scrimmage.

Judd isnt dirty, but the bloke that told the story is one hell of a cry baby

Do you mean Nick Walsh?

That's right.....I got the name wrong. It was Nick Walsh. He didn't strike me as a "cry-baby".

Sure does to me. Anyway one of them really kicked on....

Nick Walsh-moan moan moan, groan groan groan

Don't worry, Nick got back.

[quote name='Axis of Bob'

What did he do,Loges?