I know people are going to jump down my throat about this but, Scully and Bailey are really close mates so sacking Bailey isnt really an option atm because there isnt alot on the coaching market.

Malthouse- going to stay at the pies in some other role

Roos- dosent want to coach

Clarkson- Why would u leave a team that still has a chance at winning a flag in the next couple of years????

Williams- at GWS

A new rookie coach would be a huge step backwards, give dean a 2yr extension!!!

The simple fact of the matter is our blokes just arent physically ready yet. Today Hawthorn had too much experience and power for us.

Hawks have: Mitchell, Sewell, Hodge, Burgoyne, Gibson, Osbourne, Hale, Franklin, Bateman, Lewis plus Roughead to Ours Moloney, Green, Frawley, Sylvia, Jones?????

Its not rocket science thats how far ahead of us they are.

Did anyone hear on mmm that Schwabb said we can beat the giants offer and tom is starting to get frustated with the whole thing?

I'm sorry but since when do we make a decision on our coaching based on what one pimply faced kid wants?

Scully has no say, should have no say, and frankly I'm sick of the notion that this kid is running the show with his demands. I doubt it's true, and even if it was, we wouldn't be listening to him.

If Bailey is not the best coach we can have in 2012, then he should be gone.

Exactly. Who cares how close Scully and Bailey are? If the question is even being raised as to Bailey's coaching ability, we should be looking at other coaches.

Strange OP. I'm not sure what Scully has to do with your points on retaining Bailey, aside from the headline. Then you come back to another unrelated Scully subject.

Seems like you have combined two topics that already exist just so you can start your own thread.

Utter rubbish on so many grounds that it's not funny.

Any chance that the mods could do the right thing with this trash?

Actually Freddy, there is.

This thread is closed.

There is ample room elsewhere to express your opinions on Tom Scully no matter how misguided or illogical they might be.

Thank you.