With the footy season coming to an end, I’m posting a series of Hypothetical scenarios relating to AFL and would like to know what you would do in that situation. (5 part series)

Monday 11 October, Chris Judd has just announced he wants to leave Carlton in a surprise shock that rocks the footballing world.

Rest of the scenario is here ----> http://thebigtip.com.au/afl/hypothetical-no-1-chris-judd-or-out

Please post your reasoning behind your desicion, just thought this would be a bit of fun.

Cheers.

Good luck for next season. Demons will always be my second team.

North Melbourne ?

OUT: Because : -

1/ he wouldn't fit under Norths 92.5% Salary Cap.

I honestly would not target Judd with Melbournes current list, one he would be Ultra expensive im assumming, and two i am very happy with the direction in which our list is headed, especially with midfielders such as Scully, Trengove, Gysberts, Davey, Sylvia, Mckenzie, Moloney, Jones,even green with players such as Blease, strauss and pick 12 and *Viney*

Temptation is what he could provide more in a leadership role but i belive we are making the right steps and they arnt baby ones at this stage in my eyes.

Stay the course

There should be an anti Judd policy around these here parts. Nothing against your little website or anyting- Demon people and the like have been discussing Judd long enough now. We should just leave him alone to think about his actions and deal with the consequences, and live his life.