i dont understand what people are so upset about he wanted to leave, well things like that happen often.

The fact that he just walked out, well do you really think we would of goten any thing for him ?

I wasnt happy when he walked out but now couldn't care less. If CJ couldnt get a regular game last year with the state Melbourne were in then i think it was in his best interest to move on and wish him all the best. I think we has handy last night for the blues and deserves a chance to be in there best 22. In the end it i hope its a win for him having a long career with Carlton and a win for Melbourne picking up Jarah. I am still very dirty on Scott Thompson leaving the club i love the way he plays his footy and he would be real asset on and off the field which is what we need. Anyone remember who or what we got for him?

A draft pick that we gave to Geelong for Brent Moloney. We may have done better using the pick in the draft.

A draft pick that we gave to Geelong for Brent Moloney. We may have done better using the pick in the draft.

yeah we got the royal screw job there,teach us for drafting a snotty nosed crow eater, hes probably best mates with HEWITT,hes turned out to be a elite player the filthy rat.

Just another player in another jumper, couldn't give a rats

Yes. Sums it up perfectly.

A draft pick that we gave to Geelong for Brent Moloney. We may have done better using the pick in the draft.

Sounds good... until you see who was available in that draft. Not much on offer.

I think he will be a reasonable player for Carlton. He will be better than Sylvia. People forget that if it wasn't for the father\son rule he would definately have been a top 10 pick. I'm disappointed that he's gone but I think we have a pretty good replacement for him in Grimes. I'm not sure if I'm happy with the deal we got, Jurrah seems to be a fair way off from playing AFL footy and may never make it. If he begins to show something then I may be happy with the situation but he has to do something first.

I think he will be a reasonable player for Carlton. He will be better than Sylvia. People forget that if it wasn't for the father\son rule he would definately have been a top 10 pick. I'm disappointed that he's gone but I think we have a pretty good replacement for him in Grimes. I'm not sure if I'm happy with the deal we got, Jurrah seems to be a fair way off from playing AFL footy and may never make it. If he begins to show something then I may be happy with the situation but he has to do something first.

Will be a better player then sylvia????? He was lucky to be in the best 22 with melbourne, likely to be the same at Vi$y. Lets see where they are both at in 12mths time. The fact we got nothing out of the deal is a reflection on CJ and Carltank. I hope the football gods strike them both down!

if it wasn't for the father\son rule he would definately have been a top 10 pick.

can you substantiate that please