Mick, you weren't the goal umpire were you? What happened mate?

Blooooody Matthew Whelan, running in slight angle 20m out. I'm waiting for him to kick it way above my head. The idiot floats it head high, with a Collingwood bloke running back to try to touch it. I try to get on the line and end up lying on the turf as the Collingwood player runs right through me!

That said, it was the most exciting part of the match...

Awfully boring.

Haha, man you got to judge a Whelan goal, you have to earn it!! That's funny stuff

WTF. Why is Pendlebury playing VFL?

His brother

Jamar - Played really well i thought. Got his fair share of posessions, made some terrible mistakes by hand, but a majority of his posessions were effective.

C. Johnson - BOG. Made one or two mistakes but his disposal usually was excellent.

Whelan - A step above this level. The way he played he may as well have played for Melbourne.

Carroll - Just a game from Chopper.

Holland and Newton did not play. Which means Holland may play tomorow.

I think Jamar is stiff not to be in even though I don't rate him I think he has been rucking better than P.J.

If Bailey's is picking on form C.J should have got a game in front of Yze, Dunn and Bode.

Whelan should never be left out of the team for this long he is just too good.

In the Age they wrote that Carroll was awesome on that dud Egan. Gavin Brown said that we just couldn't stop him. I don't want to see Carroll in the seniors but I thought you should know that the Age wrote exactly the opposite.

I would say that Holland is still injured but I hope that he does play.

he's never been in this kind of form though has he? i can't ever remember it... his form since being droped...

Round 5 V Bendigo: 4th best to Summers, Valenti, Crowe

Round 6 V Williamstown: Not named in best.

Round 7 V Tasmania: Best on ground.

Round 8 V Northern Bullants: 2nd best on ground to Yze.

Round 9 v Collingwood: Best on Ground.

Form like this needs to be rewarded. And I believe Chris will justify his selection once he finally pulls on the red and blue...

Thanks for that, I was going to ask for it

2 BOGS, a 2nd and a 4th in 5 consecutive weeks is very good form. Will surely come in next week for whoever gets injured or for the worst of Bode, Bartram, Yze, Dunn, Bell

I must say I see very little in him, but these continual Sandy reports do seem to indicate he has turned some sort of corner. Get into it son!

its actally trent zomers birthday today!

happy birthday zomertron

No one, I don't think, has mentioned him, but I reckon Stef Martin was fantastic for Sandy yesterday.

His judgment has improved phenomenally, and, although he doesn't get huge amounts of the ball, he is a fantastic spoiler.

I think Jamar is stiff not to be in even though I don't rate him I think he has been rucking better than P.J.

Admittedly I only saw the last quarter but I thought PJ did extremely well around the ground and he won the couple of tap outs I saw too