Jaded No More

Agreed. He was fine. Should have nailed his shot on goal tho. But considering what a big [censored] deal was made about him coming to Port and making their midfield the best in the league, you gotta laugh that they got smashed by Dangerfield, Bews, Atkins and Dempsey. Only Holmes is a serious star in that lot.

Port losing to Geelong at home, who were missing arguably their most important player in Stewart, was an all time great choke. Port has a great midfield on paper. In reality, their midfield has proven not to do much in finals. I know Butters was injured, so I'll give him a pass, but Rozee their captain with just 16 touches and JHF with 18 is very uninspiring. When a 36 year old is your best midfielder, you have to worry.

100 times better than Schache. A proven marking forward and goal kicker. Good injury cover and role player. If he costs us less than nothing, I’m all for it.

I'm sorry, what?

Hasn't that worked out well for them. They've been the envy of the AFL for so long

Lucky for us footy clubs are not in the business of screwing each other. What comes around goes around. We traded more than fairly for McAdams, and Adelaide will not want to short change us on Nibbler. In this business, you get a lot more done being fair than you do stomping your feet like a petulant child. Just ask Dodoro.

That’s not actually what he said. He said the club isn’t shopping him around, but that we’ve been approached with an offer (maybe multiples?) and haven’t outright rejected it. I reckon we’ve been approached by clubs for multiple players. Other clubs can smell blood. Just as I’m sure clubs are in contact with the likes of West Coast and any other club that’s seen to be struggling or in a review process. I complete believe what @goodwindees has posted, but even he clarified his original post as I think it made it seem like we are actively trying to trade Clarry, which is not the case. He even said later on thar he believes Clarry will stay.

Anyone seen what our mate Kane Cornes is up to? Getting stuck into Port’s terrible culture I assume

So you’d take two first rounders even if those were in the late teens? Theres a big difference between two top 10 picks and two first round picks.

He is an exceptionally good player and would make us better. There is no doubt about it. If our midfield was stacked and we still had Gus I reckon we would be fine to trade away pick 5. However this season showed us that midfielders are the priority and pick 5 will likely get us a good one. I still think that the Houston deal changed when we realized how good our first round pick was going to be. When we were in the top 8, we were willing to trade it and probably made it known to Port. But things change. Besides, St Kilda wouldn’t be getting Houston if they were not losing Battle and getting a ridiculous first round compo pick in return. As if he’s worth that! There essentially swapping Battle for Houston.

I’m not surprised. They tried last year why not try again? Good luck convincing Clarry to move to Adelaide.

So you’re a liar the same way you claim everyone else here is?

Never tear us apart* *finals not included

I think Trac will continue to explore his options no matter what we do as a club. Regardless, you do not let players make list management decisions for you.

I [censored] loath them, but credit where it’s due. Their inability to die is something else.

If the club thought that, then why chase Houston? Why not trade Viney? You might think we are in a rebuild phase, but I don’t think the club agrees. Besides Oliver just turned 27, he’s not exactly hitting retirement. He easily has 6 great years left in him if he gets himself back to fitness.

3 very different scenarios but I take your point Also none of the 3 you mentioned achieved even a smidge of what Clarry has in red and blue.

Hope he enjoys all that finals success does JHF and his porn mustache.

That doesn’t come into affect until next year.

Trade rumours won’t get this site into legal trouble, nor are they slanderous towards anyone so I guess it’s not necessary to have them verified before they get posted. In normal seasons, trade rumors keep this board spicy. But I understand why it’s not a fun read these days.

To be fair Goodwindees has years of impeccable sources and a good track record. He’s not some random who signed up today to post trash. I think we are all just feeling trade fatigue at this point and it’s not even trade week yet

It would be the biggest mistake to trade Clarry in order to appease Trac, when we all know Trac won’t stop looking for a “brand management” move. If we trade Clarry it’s because we have decided our window is shut and we are trying to capitalize on the high value players we have. Or because something amazing has fallen into our lap and we need the picks to make it happen.

And why would we accept a trade if we don’t clear his entire salary off the book?

St Kilda willing to trade a first round pick. We are not. Embarrassing for who?

Port