Jaded No More

True, especially with Bartram still out. Perhaps they'll surprise us all, and choose someone like Buckley to replace Junior. Bruce or Green can tag. In fact, we should be able to beat their ruckman-less midfield without tagging them. Even without Junior. As long as Brock, Jones, TJ, Bruce and Green are up and running, we'll have them covered IMO. Oh who am I kidding, Godfrey is a certain starter <_<

No mention of that on Ch. 10 news. Said Rivers and Byron will have fitness tests tomorrow, along with plenty of Saints who are under injury clouds. Reiwoldt is unlikely to play, with Kosi and a couple of others only a 50-50 chance.

Has that kid ever made it to Round 1 un-injured? Hopefully it rains, or at the very least Reiwoldt doesn't play, thereby reducing the need for Rivers.

3 more sleeps.... :D :D :D :D

Congratulations, you just won the award for most ridiculous comment written on Demonland, ever. Oh and yeah, the club should appoint Bruce captain because he isn't injury prone... except for those seasons where he got injured and missed a huge part of the year because of those injuries, and when he came back he wasn't having any impact (unlike McLean, who came back from his injuries and made significant impact).

4 more sleeps... :D :D :D :D (18 degrees with rain is the early forecast. Brock for BOG! )

That just proves that you don't read what I write, instead you pop up whenever you feel like picking a fight. Too bad for you that I have better things to do in life than indulge your childish needs. I agree with SJ, Bruce doesn't have 'inspirational' written all over him. He isn't very intimidating, despite being a very VERY good footballer (again for those who can't read... a very VERY good footballer), and he doesn't strike me as the type to stand up for his mates in a battle and drag their sorry behinds over the line. When you compare him to great leaders like Voss or Roo, his ability might not be too far behind, but the killer instinct is just not the same. Talking about the way he trains or prepares for games is irrelevant. Yze is apperantly the most prepared, best- trained player at Melbourne, does that make him worthy of being captain? Of course these elements are important, but there is an apperant lack of ruthlessness about Bruce. When Neitz is out there, you know he will hurt anyone who gets in his way, as will Brock. I can't say the same for Bruce. This doesn't make him less of a player of course, and he is still enormously important to our side. But just because someone is a good player, does not mean they will make a good leader. There is absolutely no debate over his ability as a player. None.

I love that you can sum this up in 3 lines. Absolutely spot on.

Because we'd rather be safe than sorry. Most people are well aware of who Players A, B & C are. If people can't figure it out, they can do a bit of investigating or they can try and PM the original poster to see if he wants to give them the information.

Well I guess thats one less genuine star to put on the table during Judd negotiations. Very happy to see players signing early though. It makes for a less nerve-wrecking trade week.

True, but they will be underdone, and so if our new fitness regime is really as good as what we've heard, we should run all over them in the last quarter. Lyon is kidding himself if he thinks he has inhereted a list that is as physically strong as the Swans. Recent history would suggest that the Saints are highly sensitive when it comes to injuries, and many of their players break down consistently, especially when played underdone. Maybe Lyon will pull out the tape from the last time we played each other, the same game where the Saints ended up having no bench. At least back then it was a must-win final. Friday night is only the beggining. I just hope that Melbourne don't act as desperately as the Saints, and play Rivers, Pickett or Bartram if they are underdone. It's a long season!

First kick: McLean .......................................... First handball: Green .......................................... First free received: Neitz (yeah right! ) .......................................... First free given away: Carroll (in the back rule) .......................................... First goal: Neitz (as a result of the free for, or just because he likes tearing the Saints a new one :D) ..........................................

Talk about manipulating the argument! I never said Bruce wasn't a great player, in fact I'm pretty sure I made it very clear that he is one of our best. But if I remember correctly, you were one of many who were dirty with Bruce a couple of years ago. Yes, he was good last year, and yes he was injured the year before, but he was also very much in the same group along with Yze and Green and some other senior players who often didn't go hard enough, and often didn't show up when it mattered most. Has he changed since? Yes, absolutely (not as much as Green mind you), does that automatically make him captain material? I don't think so. My expectations of Bruce are very reasonable. I want him to perform at his best 9 out of 10 games, and I'm confident he can do that. I don't expect him to lead the team while he does it though. My argument isn't that Bruce is not a good enough player to be captain, it's that he isn't a natural leader. If we were appointing captains on skills alone, we'd have to hand the job over to TJ... a perfect example of why it takes more than an ability to play, to be a good leader.

Sheahan's list means nothing, for one, the guy is infatuated with Joel Bowden. Enough said really. McLean will be in the top 20 by the end of the year (given no injuries), I bet my entire shoe collection on it. :D

He was one of 4 Vice Captains, as not one of the 4 leaders under Neitz were given official titles of "Vice" or "Deputy Vice", but that's all irrelevant details really. As I said at the time, he has the potential to be a future captain. All eventual captains start out as deputies in the leadership group, and Miller was no different. The only thing that is holding him back from being a great leader, is finding consistency on the field, and while Bruce is undoubtedly a much better footballer, he too is prone to long acts of disappearance and IMO he is not a born leader (of course this is purely an outsiders observation, and I could be wrong). Glad you have time to search through the archives for things I said two year ago.

This is quite old (I think it was recorded in 2003), however Kerr's behaviour lately doesn't suggest to me that a whole lot has changed. From a criminal side of things, transporting the drugs interstate would be a serious offence I would imagine, and ABC news suggested that there was evidence of this happening in the phone conversations. BTW, was I the only one who heard him say to the dealer, "we're playing Melbourne at home... should beat them". Mind you, this was 2003 and we were absolutely rubbish that year . The [censored] is seriously going to hit the fan in regards to this drug issue. Now that the cat is out of the bag so to speak, revelations of drug use will come thick and fast. I'm still not convinced that it will stop the Eagles from being successful though... unless of course they decide Kerr needs a holiday too.

He probably won't. Sunday will be the first day of pre-season for him. He has a lot of work to do until his fitness is up to scratch. Besides, we need to see how he pulls up. I agree though, it is better than expected news that he's playing.

Just on ABC 7pm news.... The police have recorded conversations between drug dealers as part of an undercover investigation. One of the conversations recorded was between two drug dealers discussing Cousins and Kerr, another conversation was between Kerr and his drug dealer. Kerr was telling the drug dealer how the drugs he took made him feel very strange and forget where he was. I think they said it was a horse sedative that he bought. Funnily enough, the dealer asked Kerr about the following week's game, and Kerr said "we're playing Melbourne at home, we should beat them"... didn't stop him from tearing us a new one unfortunately! <_< The plot thickens now, and it will be interesting to see what West Coast does with this new information.

For those who missed it.... - Excited pre- season is over, and is looking forward to next Friday. - Not many injuries from pre-season, which is very good. - Very happy to play on Friday night first up. Acknowledged the fact that we have a good draw, especially having 4 home games in the first 4 rounds. - Need the 26 year olds (TJ, Bruce, Green) to step up and play well - Dunn may be back a bit quicker than first thought. Was running today already. - Frawley will miss first 3-4 games, which Neale is very disappointed about. Sounded like he was keen to play him sooner rather than later. - River is a bit sore, and they are waiting to see how he pulls up next week. 60-40 he’ll play Round 1. - To be up in the top 4, or top 2, you need to have strong finances. Neale encouraged everyone to sign up, and get us that extra help in finishing top 4. Financially we are doing well. - Improvement will come not from Neitz, White or Pickett necessarily, but from TJ, Bruce and Green in particular. Also McLean, Sylvia (hasn’t played anywhere near his best), Bate, Dunn, Jamar, Bartram, Bell and CJ (has had a tremendous pre-season and is about to blossom according to Neale). - Wants Yze to just play solid footy at 30 years of age. Didn’t sound confident about it though - Said Robbo will naturally improve now that he is fit again - Hoping Beamer and Biz will come back after injuries last year, and help the side. - Hoping to get to a good start this year, and obviously stop the late-season slump. The aim is to have everyone available at the end of the year - Ox said all the players are thrilled with Bodan and the new fitness training. - Neale acknowledged that we can’t have 3 or 4 of our best players out come August/ September - Haven’t been able to win on the long grounds and we are actively working to improve on that. - Membership around 25,000- 26,000 (I think that’s what they are hoping to get, not what we are currently at). He promoted heavily the $40 MCC membership option. Callers Questions & Answers: Q: Will PJ be given a shot in 2007? A: He had a good pre-season, but is our third ruckman at the moment as he is still learning the craft. Could play KP, maybe even take over from Neita in the future. Can’t play three ruckman though, although very important to have a back-up just in case the situation like last year arises. Q: Will Whitey play more up forward (this was asked by Ox) A: Probably, especially to give Jamar more of a go in the ruck. White won’t have as much ground time this year, which will keep him going late into the year Q: Should I put Miller in my dream team? (yes, this was asked by a 10 year old) A: We really want to play him forward as he presents very well, but he still needs to be able to play both ends of the ground (Neale didn't know much about this dream team deal). I may have missed a few things, as I was listening, typing and doing homework all at the same time He sounded absolutely pumped for Friday night though, and very focused! GO DEES!

You don't know what was happening behind closed doors. A club can only do so much. It took a while, but they finally realised that there are some things they can't deal with, and drug addiction is one of those things. They are not equipped to help a player kick a drug habit. I don't blame them for keeping all this stuff quiet. Would you want our club to air all its dirty laundry in public? I'm not saying West Coast are innocent in all this, far from it. They should have done more to get to the bottom of these rumours, but at the same time, you can see why they chose to stick their head in the sand and let their players win a premiership. I bet if they were in Carlton's position on the field, things would have boiled over much quicker. Success can cover up a lot of ugliness.

I still stand by my comment that Miller has a lot of leadership potential. If you read back you'll see that I clearly stated that your captain does not have to be your best player. At the time when I wrote this, the club had the same views as me, because they appointed Miller a Vice Captain. If he continued on from 2005, instead of getting injured in 2006 and having a poor season, he would still be in the leadership group and people would be throwing his name up along with Bruce, Brock and Green. I cannot forsee injuries or form slumps. Are you saying that Brock may have a form slump and find himself in the same situation as Miller? I guess that could happen. Bruce could also injure his knee tomorrow and spend a year on the sidelines, or stuff up the shoulder again (heaven forbid). We can't predict what will happen in a month, a year, or 5 years from now. The point I was making is that you can't teach leadership. McLean is a born leader, so is Miller. Say what you want about his skills, or his footy brain, you can't deny his leadership qualities, in fact I'm pretty certain that it was the main reason we drafted him. BTW, I never advocated to appoint Miller captain straight away (notice the word 'future'). He still had a lot to prove, and still does. Brock on the other hand, has done more than Miller at this stage. CB, I stand corrected, he did play a big part in winning that final in 2000. But as you said, that was a long time ago. Would be great to see him do that again!

Bruce is not our best player (well you could argue that he is or he isn't), and besides, a captain doesn't necessarily have to be your best player. He has to be right up there, but there is more to being a captain than having skills. I'm going to wait and see whether Bruce can play consistently throughout the season, and more importantly win us a final. He is yet to do that, in fact, up until last year he was one of many senior players who went missing in September. I don't see the point in delaying the inevitable. Brock will be captain one day, having an in-the-meantime captain seems like a pointless exercise. Age has nothing to do with leadership, you either have it or you don't... Brock has plenty of it.

We teach these kids to become elite footballers, we're not a babysitting service! If he has to be told to come to training, he won't cut it at an AFL level.

You're right on all these issues, particularly the consistency one. In fact, McLean is the equal most productive player on the ground along with Judd. He averages 22.4 disposals a game, hardly inconsistent. I don't remember too many games where he played and had no impact. He also has the ability to come straight back from injury and dominate, that's rare. He is my next captain, and I'm hopeful that come the end of this season everyone will agree.

Well that explains his mysterious absence for Sandy games. Hope the kid gets his head right. This is a once in a lifetime opportunity for him, it would be a shame if he blew it.