demon3165

Wow a functional forward line who would have thought that, maybe just a thought we could try that...

With closed eyes, but anyway.

Jesus did you even look at it, you said Gus kicked on his left wrong, you lot are so one eyed is become a joke, as I have said so many times the initial act ok the end was not and should have been suspended, if he had continued with arms up no problem you guys are trying your dislike for someone to justify it.

Gus was running forward so he was moving closer to Maynard as I have repeatedly said if Maynard had kept his hands up and collided with Gus it would have not the same impact. Players are taught to protect their body and it becomes natural to them, if he really wanted to deliberately wanted to take him out he would not have been in the air around the same time as the ball hit the boot.

Brayden Maynard Bump_Spoil.mp4

Gus kicked it on his right foot so that's wrong for a start, Maynard was just starting to jump as Gus kicked it I have tried to up load it but it says it's to big that would show it.

Jesus look at the video through two eyes not red and blue, i don't have a problem with his first action of smothering and yes i would have suspended him because he turned his body but that is what players have been shown for years as i said earlier if he had just collided with Gus with two hands up Gus would have been ok. Gus was only one concussion away from retiring it just happed to be that one.

I look at things in a different light and I see the Maynard not as a deliberate act to take Gus out and you are casting aspersions on someone's character without facts just emotion. As for your other point I have been saying the same thing about the midfield and forward line for 2 years and people said I am wrong now people see it. Our backline will be OK corrections need to be in the midfield and the forward line well that's been dysfunctional for 2 years but can be corrected with a good forward line coach and recruitment, but unless the skills and decision making of the players further up the ground improve any forward line will struggle with the way the ball comes in. Will Goodwin chance or stay the course we will soon see.

Well that's your opinion not mine at the end of the day it's not affecting my life or players lives.

Those side are not that flash, Port are hit and miss Doggies well depends what side turns up but yes maybe i am little to optimistic but deep down hopeful but whatever happens change will come next year.

Do you know if Gus has spoken to Maynard you seem to think so so don't assume on that point but if you want to go that analogy past players at Melbourne shouldn't talk to Grinter after what he did to wallace? I have explained my thoughts on Maynard incident and for the benefit of you I will say it again, yes the start of the act was legal but the contact was not and I will also say this when Maynard turned his body and all footballer's are taught to turn their body before contact to protect themselves like he did that is where he should have gotten suspended, if Maynard had continued with arms up and had contacted Gus the damage would have been limited, the same as Peter Street earlier nt the year if he had continued to spoil it would have only been a fifty metre penalty. For people to say Maynard deliberately did do that is so so stupid and limited in their thinking because emotion takes over critical thinking. I will also say and people should realise Gus was only one more concussion away from retirement whether this year or another time, Gus is a smart person and he will be OK.

Port, GWS, doggies, eagles, and north are winnable if we play right but the others no, but football is a funny game.

Because he's not a child unlike some here.

Why do they have to explain anything, they have to the AFL subject over, people thinking clubs have to explain everything to supporters that would be their only job.

Seems some children have been let out of the creche....

I am sure everyone will research and gather more information on such matters and that will only be a good thing going forward more education is a good thing.

I find it amusing by the amount of medical people on this site and we're in the rooms to give their opinion on his injury, you are complicit for not insisting enough that he should not go back on, Jesus the AFL has ticked it off that should be enough but no demonland go in hysterics without knowing the facts. Hope Trac takes his time to recover.

Oh by the way, best you research before writing something, I have been saying the same thing in 22 and 23 so at least I have been consistent in my views.

You are the one trolling and it's simple block me then you don't see my posts or is that to hard to figure out, I write what I see, agree with people on their views or I disagree with my view and that's the difference between you and me I don't follow blindly without putting something forward unlike you so do yourself a favour and don't reply or take a panadol and a good rest.

Oh there we go, nothing intelligent to contribute but trying to give a drive by, back to school little one see if you can pass kindergarten this year.

My view on those Fullarton from what I have seen and limited like Schache has skills but not intense at the contest. McAdam as a forward is not the main target type of player more the second or third player who can bob up. Billings game plan clearly does not suit him an outside player. Hunter last year. Now Kentfield, likes contact clearly has football smarts showed that last week in limited time and likes contact at the ball all he needs is a fitness base.

You would be that person on the titanic when it started to take water getting on the microphone saying it's OK folks it's only a little water get back to you cabins and have fun, so tell us what happened against Freo and a weakened Collingwood side where did we go wrong and how to fix it I'm interested for your opinion on this and what do we need to improve as a side I'm open minded on this so over to you...

Can agree with that view.

Find it moronic that you don't know what it is but there you go.

Must have pretty low standards if you are calling jordon, Bedford, hunt and harmes A graders.