Maldonboy38

6. Petracca 5. Oliver 4. Viney 3. Sparrow 2. Chandler 1. Grundy

SChache is a poor man's Jack Watts. With ball in hand he is a good kick, and good decision maker. But when it comes to him getting the ball.... so ineffective and non impacting.

Chandler building a nice little CV. I wasn't expecting him to be as clean and hard working as he is. Really impressed with him.

Shocking error. No free kick there.

This is very easy to watch, but feels a bit like an intra club sim. But nothing can excuse North from this display. This is Gold Coast and GWS 2013, 2014. It doesn't even look VFL standard. That mark Kozzie took is a brutal embarrassment to the insipid North player who let it happen.

Freo and Swans not playing finals after today. Even if they recover players, and get some wins. Not up to it in 2023. And Toby Greene used to do some horrible stuff on the ground, but he is an absolute A grader. Matchwinner.

Lions v Freo is just boring to watch. Switched over to GWS v Swans. Not much better. I know a lot of water has passed under this bridge, but Hogan with his body right, mind right, and in form is a great footballer.

Goodwin has spoken openly about exploring forward line options, so I can't see our forward line being too functional or explosive. And Clarkson will try and bring this game down with lots of stoppages, lots of short passes at half back, and lots of attempted switching off half back which rarely works against the Dees. Goldstein will match us in the ruck, but our midfield will slaughter North's, and our backline can readily manage Zurhar etc... - the only real threat is Larkey who I rate very very highly. Dees by 40 points.

4 years ago I never wanted the ball in his hands. I thought him a shanker and a momentum killer and would have been glad to trade or delist. Glad I don't make list decisions because he trained hard, developed well and is an integral piece of the Dees Goodwin-footy. He runs both ways, has a team first attitude, has improved his skills each year and is now more than reliable. Not perfect, and not an A grader but an experienced, steady, composed, team man whose defensive work is epic, and he knows how to kick a goal when the chance comes his way. Also, it was when he kicked his goal in the last quarter of the 2021 GF, that I turned to my daughter and said "I think we've got it".

It is a bit of a yawn, but anyway... Although the consultancy fees involved in the process are disgusting, it has to be a long, thorough process to find a suitable candidate for an organisation the size, wealth and influence of the AFL. I'm glad they have taken their time. Having said that, it feels a little bit like a cookie-cutter appointment. A little bit "son of the regiment" which refers to military appointments being given to children of previous in-house high-ranking officers because they represent the desires of those committed to the system. He has to be able to oversee the Tassie expansion, along with the brutal and unavoidable conversation that will emerge around the 20th license. He has to manage the AFLW expansion. I hope he is the right man.

May looks off his best and possibly carrying an injury, so Turner in for him. Spargo another week away. I will never be convinced of Dunstan or Shache as AFL footballers. Our forward set up is better with BBB in it, but he has to be fit and able enough. If he comes in, Rivers or Sparrow to the sub., Laurie back to Casey unfortunately.

Happy to go hard for elite talent, but 3 picks for one player seems too much for me. Taylor and Lamb know what they are doing, so I am very relaxed watching how they play this out. The main issue for me, is how long will our current window last? I call it the Gawn window, because when he retires, we will probably lose May, BBB & TMac won't last as long as Gawn, and Viney will possibly have a shorter career because of the way he plays. Trac, Oliver, Salem, Lever et al... will be nearing the end of their careers. So, this Gawn window is open for another 3-4 years. Our recruiting at the end of this year has to be about the post Gawn era. For that reason, I prefer NOT to go after a single player, but prefer 2 or 3 top 20 players who can be part of the next generation.

Great game of footy. If it continues at this pace, everyone will tire, and it becomes a big man's game. At this point Essendon's rucks might make the difference, like Gawn and Grundy did last night in the last quarter. If the Pies win, my tipping is 9/9. I loathe Essendon. I hope the Pies win, but I feel impure typing it.

He's always had it - he needs a long run of games to find/produce it. He never was allowed a full season in the 22 to find his game with us. If van Rooyen was the Weid, he would have been subbed and dropped next week. Scott is backing him in and encouraging him to simply go for it. I always liked him, but in the end the selectors went with other options. But I can't stand that he chose the Bombers. I hate it that I like the Weid but hate his club and jumper.

I have slept on it all, read over the posts added to this thread today, had my morning coffee, and can now be a tad more reasonable about reflecting on last night. This was a Dees Goodwin win. His ethos is that the 22 can reset after any play, goal, break etc... Last night, it took us longer to reset than usual. Often, if we have a bad quarter, we reset at the break, or at half time. But things didn't change or turn until half way through the 3rd quarter. But we did reset, the game turned, and we surged ahead. The last quarter was us at our best. Dogged. Manic. Fierce. Lots of little extras, one percenters, off the ball hard work. Richmond were very good at ground level, while we were atrocious for 3 quarters. JVR and Chandler - wow. Although they were collectively responsible for a lot of the poor skills and messy decision making, our central body of players need more credit for the win: ANB, Jordon, Sparrow, McVee, Bowey, Brayshaw, Grundy, Hibberd. These guys in the 2nd half worked their a**es off, albeit with frustrating errors involved. Gawn & Grundy and finding their partnership and I love it. We have a lot of work to do, especially forward, but we won.

Brayshaw must have snorted a line, had 5 energy drinks, drank 3 cups of coffee and had a Boost drink. He is chirping along like a chipmunk.

Now, what do we do about our poor contested ball intensity, and our horrid ground ball skills in our defensive 50? The Tigers ripped us apart in these 2 areas tonight. If Dusty kicked straight we probably lost. A major and persisting issue - terrible handballing. Inaccurate, wrong choice, to a player under pressure, high loopy blind dangerous ones, players having to stop running to take them. Poor in every way. And although only 20 touches, I hope we don't drop Jordon again. Some of his off-ball work, tackling, and defensive running tonight was so, so good.

6. Viney daylight 5. Langdon 4. Gawn 3. Lever (including a LOT of brain fades) 2. Chandler 1. JVR NOTE: Sparrow, ANB, Hunter and Jordon all worked hard but...

I cannot believe we won that game. Apart from an increasingly good last quarter, our game play, skills, and decision making were as poor as they have been in 3 years. Take a bow Jack Viney - epic game in every way. And welcome to the big time JVR.

That JVR is soft, rubbish, not up, to it, needs 2 years to develop etc... He goes alright though.

WHAT IS GOING ON WITH OUR DECISION MAKING???? AAAARRRRGGGHHHH!

Lever with 1 hand casually misses the ball. Facepalm.

Umpiring aside... I have not been up off my chair yelling at the screen since the 2021 GF, but this time it incredulous fury. It is simply not possible for a squad with this talent to make so many fundamental football errors, both in decision making AND skill. It looks like 2012/2013 /2014 team. And as for those pathetic, "get-rid-of-the-ball-quickly" handballs that go 50 cms, or the loopy one over the top so 2 Richmond players can cause physical pressure or damage, can't the on-field leadership correct that?

The last 2 minutes has been some of our cleanest method all night. Long may it continue.

Yep, swing Brayshaw into the middle and leave Trac down forward. JVR is being out-muscled but I would just get him to move more. Apart from BBB he is our best forward option and one I like. TMac is probably done, and I am no believer In Schache. We miss Salem so much. Bowey, Rivers and McVee poor tonight and making horrid decisions.