Maldonboy38

I dislike some players, and there are others who annoy me, but there are few I loathe watching. Maynard is a total anchor-with-a-w, faux tough guy and dipstick. Can't stand watching him.

Collingwood being gifted free kicks - the umpires must be listening to the commentators who will not shut up about b****y Collingwood. The Blues have woken up and are playing a very similar game to how the Dees beat the Pies - giving up the run through the wing but clogging up half forward.

6. Viney 5. Gawn 4. Kozzie 3. Brayshaw 2. Langdon 1. Chandler Apologies to Rivers and Salem

Fortunately, we know how to win. In terms of collective effort, will and hunger, we are as good as anyone. But there are some serious holes in our play which have been constant for most of the year. (brainless handballing, appalling kicking especially inside F50, and unpressured turnovers) We can get away with them against the Crows, but not against Pies, Power and Lions. Today against the Crows, 2 other issues arose which are of great concern. First - Crows players ran from behind the play to take a handball, and ran through our midfield like a hot knife through butter. They did it unabated all day. We stuck a few great tackles at times, but their run and carry tore us apart. Secondly, our decision making around contested ball or coming through half back. Wow. I have no idea what has happened to Stephen May but he was putrid. Great to see Kozzie and Chandler play really well. Loved the hard work of BBB and JVR. Not huge stats but they worked bl**dy hard. Likewise Sparrow. Max and Jack Viney - I salute you.

I hate our field kicking at times. Can someone perhaps, maybe, possibly, just man up on Rankine.

He's a really good footballer, but much more limited if you let him play wide. When we beat the Pies, both Daicos boys were rarely allowed to be more than 2-3 metres from an opponent and had little impact.

Mason Cox - hahahahahaha!!

Do either of Geelong or Brisbane know they are playing FOOTball, and not HANDball? So much ineffective, unnecessary handballing all over the ground. Kills me.

Haven't been able to watch any footy this weekend, until now. I sit down to watch Lions v Cats, and it is an absolute howler of a game. No highlights, dominated by defensive efforts, skill errors.

To quote Keats: "a thing of beauty is a joy forever". The lower those (insert derogatory expletive here) fall, the more beautiful is the joy.

A qualified yes from me, but he is only mid-range for salary. Pros: He breaks lines, has genuine speed, and can have huge impact moments in games that begin periods of momentum. Cons: Kicking is average, has periods of weeks in a single season where he is in poor form, and he wants to leave because he is not playing where he wants (me first attitude) I reckon Choco would be great for him.

I rate him highly as a 200 gamer, meat-and-three-veg kind of player. Not a star player with a specific set of skills that set him apart, but does all the required things well. For mine, he is ahead of both Harmes and ANB as a midfield/utility. It appears that the selectors have him 'ranked' just behind Sparrow but I have them on an even par The issue is, he is on the edge of our best 22/23 and would slot into 14 of the other clubs easily. I really hope he stays, but reckon we have already lost him. He has been sub or dropped too many times.

The word is hubris. Total, self-absorbed arrogance to rest so many starting 22 players believing the win was already in the bag. I LOATHE Carlton but glad they won tonight.

I can't believe I am enjoying watching Carlton serve it up to Port. They are doing to Port what we did to the Pies - crowding their wide-playing ball carriers and making them accountable. Pressure really works.

Tomlinson in for Petty. Spargo v Chandler is interesting. Spargo is a lot smarter, and often gets ignored when leading, but his output has been limited, error-riddled and lacks impact. Chandler is a better kick, but he was struggling to get the ball at all when he was dropped. I would give Spargo another week - lots of players are given multiple weeks to find form. Leave BBB and JVR in. They rarely get in each other's way, and keep on presenting. They may not have big numbers, but the other forwards are able to create so much due to their hard work. Smith remains sub. Another thing to consider is Adelaide's strong mid-size and small forwards. Perhaps we need to consider Hibberd in for Woewodin?

My wife had the laptop last night, watching some carp on Netflix, so I finally get a chance this morning to do the important thing - get onto Demonland! There is a part of me that still cannot believe we won that. We are a very mentally tough team. To be totally beaten up for 2 quarters, and looking unlikely to break the game open, only to emerge in the 4th quarter with a fire in the belly. Viney and Rivers were raging bulls in the last quarter and set the tone. Good to see Kozzie much closer to his best. I cannot stress how important he is. Leave Trac playing 60% forward, and leave Brayshaw in the middle. Love this setup. Trace kicking for goal when he is not exhausted from midfield running makes his set shots soooo much better. I was wrong - Melksham and Smith in the same 23 CAN work. Smith was very important in the last quarter and showed a real swing man/utility vibe. Our backline was beaten for much of the night. That doesn't happen often. Lions half back line murdered us, and we had no answer until we began wining the ball and denying them freedom in the last quarter. BBB and JVR - not great games but they presented time and time again and created opportunity after opportunity. Max - wow! Taj - that is an epic first goal. And lastly, our coach, Goody. Well done. Once again at the press conference, he showed his stubborn self belief in his program, his players and his plan. I know many Demonlanders get frustrated with his seeming lack of flexibility but I am not one of them. Our bad patches and losses are NOT about game plan, coaching box lethargy, lack of vision etc...

6. Gawn 5. Viney 4. Petracca 3. Brayshaw 2. Rivers 1. Melksham

Our good looks very good, our bad looks horrible. So many chances with ball in hand, only to kick it to a Lions defender. Great game of footy, but our mistakes could cost us... again. Our poor kicking into F50 has raised its head again We need to cover Coleman more quickly. Viney is a weapon

ANB - you kill me. Melksham not far behind.

The news is sad, but not unexpected. I actually rate Dew highly as a coach, but the pattern of fade outs in the 2nd half of the season had to demand blood at some point. With a lot of younger players 'buying in' recently, I can imagine some of them will be furious, but they also have to take some of the blame.

Leave Trac 50%= game time as a froward. Midfield of Viney, Sparrow and Jordon. I would also run Rivers and Kozzie through there. Perhaps some pressure and time in the guts will give Kozzie back his early season spark. JVR back in. I. too would love to see BBB and JVR alongside each other for a few weeks. I wish Hibbo was available for Cameron. If not, I suppose it has to be Rivers or Bowie??

That's a better win than many Demonlanders are giving it credit for. 4th v 5th, lots of pressure. Not perfect, and not our best, but a good win. F50 play looked as good as it has all year. If BBB wasn't blocked all night it would have looked even better. Fumbling mostly fixed. Horror handballing unfortunately back in a big way. May and our backline are immortals. Not sure why we kicked long to so many forward contests where Kozzie, Spargo and ANB were the targets. Ground ball and spread from contests continues to be a worry. The Saints killed us at these 2 things tonight.

6. May 5. Viney 4. Salem 3. Petracca 2. Sparrow 1. Brayshaw

A crumbing ground ball win from Woewodin. Keep him in the side!

Can we be first to a groundball please. and if/when we do - fumble.