Demon17

In Lamb I trust. ( plus plenty others at the club)

Post of the week. Well done BD.

I like this possibility. Young Brayshaw is a gun and will be for 10 years. Sure wer'e exposed losing Jackson, but would Freo trade out their next skipper?

The Blues invented rorting in the 80's being the John Elliott legacy and nicely handed over the batten to the club in 2000's via Judd's alledged $200K Environmental ambassadorship with Visy. Could be a clue.

Lloyd was the only sensible voice on that show re: this issue and sees it from a champion players perspective. Its a distraction to Dees fans, as was Hogan, but after the Hogan saga, I'm immmune now to this and what will be will be. Hogan was a 'great hope' for the club. Now we have a team full of them, not to mention the top shelf coaching panel. In terms of the once in a generation sweet spot we have (under 30ish)... Oliver, Trac, Viney, lever, salem, Fritsch, Sparrow, Brayshaw, Petty, Pickett, Spargo, ANB, Langdon etc. Plus the young latent talent pool yet to break into the side. Plus Goodwin, Yze.... Good luck to Jacko no matter what he does.

I'm with you on this SWYL. Brown was a presence around the ground and this debate reminded me of why I like G Lyon as a commentator. He progosticates on what he sees in front of him, with insight as a former great player with a feel for the game, as opposed to say David King who seems to trawl through stats to then come up with a point to make or a theory. Make the facts fit the reality maybe?. No better was this illustrated than the Cats V Tiges call on Saturday, when Lyon smartly called for what the Tiges needed to stem the bleeding, including the move of Baker into the thick of it, and behold it and a few other moves were made by Hardwick. Not a stat quoted by Lyon, just this was how he saw the game strategically. I'm not comparing you SWYL to Lyon btw, just noting similiar appoaches in these instances. Admittedly I'm a big fan of Brown after the fianls series last year, and I think he gets a bad wrap when the ball is dropped on his head and he has trouble. He stays in for the medium term IMO

Bizarrely I was barracking for the Blues to assist with your theory about interstate teams, and hoping it helps keep Freo out of spots 1 and 2. Same with the Cats whenever they play any interstate team. Dockers have the Tigers and Dogs in Melb so thats two games that may be helpful if the home teams can get it done, but Lions only have the Tiges in Melb and a fairly soft home draw , plus Dees in fnail home game for them. With a bit of luck, and if Dees and cats keep winning, Just maybe Freo and Lions are 3 and 4 on the ladder after season.

AGreed and anytime, and Dees not having 3 concussions in 1 1/4 so the Pies would face a fit and firing full strength team.

But only if we lose in Week 1. if we win, we go straight into prelim and the gam will be at our home ground. The losing Week 1 teams lose their advantage for a prelim home game. And that transfers to the 2 winners of Top 4 teams in week1. So the trick for Goody is just get a Week 1 win done.

Yes - Sort of. If Dees play a melb based team in week 1 and we lose , we have our next final in week 2 at our home ground MCG. The downside is that there are crossovers in the finals draw so that no team plays each other twice, unless the second game is the GF. Thus if Dees lose to a Melb team, that winner gets a MCG Prelim. The Dees, if we win in Week 2, will have to play the winner of the other Week 1 top four final, and if that winner is interstate, then thats where the Dees Week 3 prelim will be. The fail safe key is what happened last year- win in Week 1 to Prelim and have that at home (usually except for Covid issues in 2021) and let the rest take care of itself. really we need to be barracking for Blues as a top 4 chance , as well as us, to at least minmise the chance of an interstate prleim.

37200. Good effort dees fans

I don't get how rucks will work. Max has a superhuman tank. He's out. What will be the rotations? If Bbb is away from the goalsquare this could be a masterstroke.

Not necessarily. Thyev'e been wrong about us the past 3 games. If they looked at whole Dees games this year they, like us, would have the seen the forward disconnect big time, with defence just keeping us in the game. Lions have to be favourites this week but as you say not according to the bookies.

Your'e right - we have the talent when fully fit and will have to this year. Many finalsist will fear a full dees list. But...... I see Top 4 now out of reach and making Top 8 will be touch and go. Can only pencil 1 more win in, against the Crwos, and maybe Port but that's not certainty either with them hitting their straps. Underdogs in the rest probably. Tomorrow night will tell.

Youv'e nailed my fear Billy on this. In early 2000's after the GF in 2000 we lost Woey. No matter the reasons, at the time I saw this as an unravelling of a team by losing a much loved member. Clarry and Gus are these types big time, plus many others. They must be looked after as 1 Club players for the Dees I love Luke jackson but culturally he isn't the glue within the club like these two are. (and that's not meant to be disparaging to Luke, just that he didn't go through the hard times and re-bulld like many others.

Great post. Luke has been off the boil these past weeks and needs to justify the hype at present IMO. He has now been handed a gold-plated opportuniy with Max out. If we snag several of the next few games, against the tide, he will have absolutely locked away his potential and worth , if not, it may just then be hype. And we move on whatever happens a la Hogan the experience and wish him well..

Every day of the week. Gus over Jackson, for the reasons you outline.

On the contray we need to look at all these 8 point games (we beat the Dons, they beat a finals rival of ours , the Saints) as a real bonus now its not absolutely certain the Dees can make the 8, and if we do this result helps us enormously re; ours finals position vs the Saints. More power to the Bombers against all top 8 sides from now on I say.

Suck on that Herald Sun. Now get onto the next fresh meat to sell your disgrace of a paper.

I love optimisim, but I am fearing a 12 - 10 finish and 9th on %. If we make Top 4 it will be heroic and confirm this team as something really special. I will currently take 8th to 5th with both hands. My views are all injury driven from last Monday . But as Matthew Lloyd says, at least we know the issues mid-season and have time on our side.

Being the afl's only playing skipper immortalised as a premiership captain , something pendles can only dream of, i suspect his high self esteem held him firm whem moronic and disrespectful epithet s came his way from the filth bench.

nailed it for many fans. But Clarry can put it into his trophy cabinet next to his premiership Medallion. 21 of the 23 pies players don't have one of those either.

Excellent effort Spirit. Joeboy to Bench I think we must have been at the same game Spirit. A very good , albeit more than 3 word, team summary. Cue evidence; Spot on about Turner. very impressed and I think the Dees may have found another.

I agree with your post but TBH I think May will not incur any further sanctions from AFL. He can demonstarte self-defence etc., drinking rule has been dealt with by club, I didn't start it .....(as you have to exclude his comments, there's no rule with being mean and uncaring to others feelings) Unfortunately I suspect it's Jake who will cop something for throwing the first one, and the whole Gerard Whately hysteria of "...violence cannot be condoned under any cirecumstances (sic)..." etc. Drug abuse and alcohol abuse both have their origins in mental health issues. Smith and May are alike in that regard. It is stupidity, but its also more than that. The difference here is that Jake alerted the club immediatley, Smith owened up months later after beuing caught out with no other options open to him and the cirus and sponsors have bought into that narrative. Cotton On would have certainly weighed the effect up his marketing value before sticking with him.. Big deal.

Great post and in regard to the Murdoch media and Caroline Wislon this morning beating up an isseu prior to 21021 season - again - there's only one other comment Goody/Pert/Roffey/Gawn/ etc etc....need to add if they wanted to from now on at media events........ "... Last time I looked the Dees/We are reigning Premiers - or did I dream it..." I type this as I am overlooked by my Team premiership Photo on the wall behind me, witha piece of the match day ball also in the display. That suggested answer is just another variation on winners are grinners and the rest can suit themselves So it wasn't a dream....was it?