old dee

Funny that thought crossed my mine, well what left of it.

Both I think deanox. But perhaps I am biased.

He doesn't have contested marking ability to compensate.

From past watching Casey and today my thoughts of the forward / ruck options who have been around for a while I believe Fullarton is the only one with enough talent to make it at AFL level. He is a bit light but has the smarts / Ability to get around that problem. Verrall Good ruckman at VFL level but slow around the ground a pity because he has the size. Jefferson Hmm Got what I expected. I hope I am the problem because every time I see him he is average at best, cannot mark when contested. Seems to just drift out of the game. Kentfield had a good game on debut. Need to see more. Of the others McAdam played well but so he should against this Pies side who make us look like champions. Too light for AFL level IMO. At the top level is you are light you need to be very good. He is not very good and at his third club. Koltyn played well but I am not sure he has the overall ability to be a force at the top Level. Still he shows a lot of promise. After all we convincingly beat the pies and at any level that makes for a good day.

IMO No mono.

Tomlinson is way to good at this level.

Best ruckman out there is Brown by a country Mile.

That sounds familiar.

Brown playing ruck and so far is good. Terrible kicking should be way in front

You are not alone

I simply asked in your view could he step up? Could he?

No Gus!

I would not have believed it 3 weeks ago.

My problem is he has a good quarter then I have to concentrate because he seems to become invisible. I have watched him on tv and to be fair that often doesn't show the whole story. Eg. On tv you seldom see when players leads etc are ignored. I was planning to go today then discovered it was at Casey.

There are 4 KPF's in that line up. So which one plays out of position? We will know in 30 mins.

Sadly I don't share your enthusiasm. If Max could not play today in your view could he step up?

Hogan was a genuine full forward from day 1. Weideman was not. JVR is ok kentfield high hopes, Jefferson nope!

Is that last line a question old55?

You think we will by that much today JJR? It's wet so will probably be low scoring.

Oh isn't winter in Victoria fun.

Strange how three weeks can markedly change your view. I now see our side as in need of some change and renewal. We miss Gus big time, our forward line is a shambles and the loss of Yze to Richmond may now be showing that he is a big loss. We seem to have lost our spark. For me this weekend is about today. I am very interested in the Casey game. The weather will have some effect but I look forward to seeing who has made progress and who shows any signs of being a top level player. I am really looking forward to seeing the new light from the west. Tomorrow is about who has the least impact from injuries. IMO neither team will win a flag in 2024 or even make the top 4.

Sadly this guy cannot spell!

It was an attempted at humour ta.

Funny Sunday night I was thinking well we have the fall back of looking forward to the draft as the highlight of the year.

We are ain't we? It is difficult to see him giving less than Petty.