old dee

Honestly this guy is not worth a lot. Injury prone and very inconsistent. 63 games in six seasons is not flash and a lot of the early games were when we were hardly More than VFL standard. He was the best of a bad lot.

I was going to upgrade for 2019 looks like the ship has sailed. one of the problems of the club improvement I guess.

You are not alone!

You have my 100% agreement dc. we should be saying this is our requirement take it or leave it.

Any player who comes onto a fan website and expects to see better than 50% support is in for a rude shock. If they want only glowing reports tell them to stick to the MFC site. It is the nature of the beast. Fan websites enable fans to put their view. Tell them to stay away is my advice.

No deal he put in his best games in the last month of the season however he is still to prove he is a 22 game player in 2019.

I looked at the photos of him and the coach from the weekend and thought if he leaves the Weagles I will be surprised.

Me too however it appears that is not going to happen. So what is the best we can achieve from the move? To honest I have little idea but you would hope we get as good a deal as Adelaide got for Lever.

I find it very funny that just 6 weeks ago when BB and some others raised the issue of Hogan being traded they were castigated in the extreme by some folk on here as idiots. Seems they were not such idiots after all. It seems significant that no one has said it is BS he is staying at the MFC. Not him, his agent, no MFC person and no one from Freo. That tells me it is going to happen.

I would not bother dc the MCC would probably lose it!

Arh no DF that might have been going a little bit too far just a few hours after the loss.

Sank am few single malts tonight with an old friend who just happens to be a Pies man. i was very magnanimous but inside I was cheering the loss. At the end of the day I still hate the bastards.

I was barracking for the Pies because I hate them slightly less than WA. also was watching with my Pies supporting wife but got to say I was not disappointed with the result. Having to put with Collingwood for the next year would have ben devasting.

Covers it beautifully Bbo.

I was referring to Jobe the Elder bb in fact very elder!

Do we really care? Winning finals and then a GF is what counts. Winning the best midfielder award is just an AFL sideshow.

So not big on him SF? To be honest have no interest in GCS so have only watched a single game of these in 2018. No idea on his ability but he must be a reasonable player to be VC one would think. Funny though replaceing a forward with a back.

Take the draft pick and punt on a kid or state leaguer

I agree he has played 63 games over 6 years. An average of 10 games per season is not flash. His body is simply not robust enough for the top level.

Me too. Two first round picks is the mininium.IMO

And so another year ends to a familiar tune Mr. Leg.

That would be a black day in hell. If we did I would retire from watching football at AFL level however I am safe.

For who?

Don't you have to make 4 selections?

That was the curtains act Wiseblood it was all over after that game.