P-man

Hannan having a mare.

Seriously. Pay T Mac whatever he wants.

Fair dinkum. It’s one quarter into the match.

Carlton fans complaining about literally every free kick lol

He always is. It’s weird.

Sublime kick from Nibbler.

At least Trac’s set shot accuracy remains unaltered.

Tackling pressure has been good. Skills have been sharp enough.

Lamb is a classic case of a spud who compensates by being a pest.

We’re on here. Good start.

Time to obliterate these mugs. Viney smash.

Will be worth the price of entry this weekend just to see these two doing their thing. Feels a little like a heavyweight bout with Cripps holding the belt and the brash 20 year old seeking to take it off him.

He'll be back. Hopefully sooner rather than later.

He didn’t get a week originally. Just a fine.

The counterargument is that the umpire shouldn’t be getting that close to a melee in the first place and Charlie was acting instinctively, perhaps even to protect the umpire. i would’ve been happy with either course of action for Charlie, but how it took this long to get the right decision for Ed is beyond me. It was clearly intentional and clearly a frustrated act. Staggering incompetence. That said, the right decision has at least been reached regarding Ed and Hawkins can feel less aggrieved. The AFL had to act and it did.

This.

At 23 I'd rather have him on the list than not, and then see how much correction can be made over the next couple of years. I think he's worth more to us than he is worth at the trade table.

lol what a mickey mouse operation. Won’t change the result.

Dude. It’s Robbo,

This umpire touching thing has an air of the citizenship saga. Happens not infrequently without a fuss being made and suddenly one particular instance has drawn attention to numerous others. That being the case, I think Ed is clearly gone given the more blatant nature of it, and Charlie should get a week based on the Hawkins precedent. May’s contact didn’t warrant a suspension. Two handy outs. Charlie for obvious reasons and Ed because of the run with role he plays most weeks.

Timing really is everything. Trac is a little down atm so he hardly gets a mention. I’d still go Oliver but this could easily be Petracca. 67 votes to 5 is not an accurate reflection of the gap between the two.

Nah. He needs games at AFL level. His talent means the next game could easily be the one he busts open. The side also feels more intimidating with Petracca on the teamsheet. He has that aura already. i agree with Tyson out for Viney. Tyson has more class than Harmes but you can only judge on performance (I know that probably contradicts my defence of Trac but he’s a rare beast ?).

The vast gap between the two sides was evident from around the five minute mark to the final siren. We absolutely bossed them, as we should have. The talent in this side is super exciting, and Fritz and Spargo are very much part of that exciting group.

Maybe put your own votes up. Or provide some sort of reasoning for why you disagree with his votes. Something actually useful.

Carlton lost to this mob by 6 goals playing at home.